DOJ Drops Alaska Senate Election Lawsuit, Cites Mixed Ballots

The Justice Department dropped its lawsuit challenging Alaska’s U.S. Senate election on Thursday, conceding the case is moot after Democrat Mary Peltola defeated incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan.

In a 19-page filing with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, federal prosecutors acknowledged that ballots have already been mixed together, making it impossible to determine whether voters who selected Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. intended to vote for the senator.

Peltola won by more than 12,000 votes, while the independent Sullivan received fewer than 5,000 — a margin that would not have changed the outcome even if every one of those votes had gone to the incumbent.

Breaking Election ALERT: Dem Mary Peltola WINS Alaska Senate race, Flipping another seat BLUE — MS NOW

Rather than let the lower court’s dismissal stand, the department asked the appeals court to vacate that ruling entirely and return the case for dismissal on mootness grounds. “The United States therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means” of determining voter intent, the filing said.

“The legal theory advanced by the United States here is embarrassing and indefensible.”

attorneys for the American Civil Liberties Union wrote in a brief representing the League of Women Voters of Alaska and Common Cause. They had asked the appellate court to summarily affirm Judge Sharon Gleason’s dismissal and to order federal attorneys to explain why they should not be sanctioned for pursuing a frivolous appeal.

The lawsuit was filed in October at President Donald Trump’s direction, seeking to block certification while authorities investigated whether the presence of two candidates with nearly identical names confused voters. U.S. District Court Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the suit, saying the federal government lacked standing, but the Department of Justice appealed to the 9th Circuit.

Alaska Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher said Wednesday she intends to certify the election next week. When seated, Peltola will join a 56-person Democratic Senate majority elected amid a nationwide surge of support for Democratic candidates.

DOJ Drops Alaska Senate Election Lawsuit, Cites Mixed Ballots
Photo: kpvi.com

The New York Times reported in late October that Dan J. Sullivan had been recruited by Democratic campaigners seeking to spoil Sen. Sullivan’s re-election bid. Federal attorneys echoed that claim Thursday, writing that the confusion was “caused (and intended to be caused) by Daniel J. Sullivan’s campaign, egged on by Peltola’s.”

While the civil lawsuit is winding down, a separate criminal investigation continues. The Anchorage Daily News reported Wednesday that both the Alaska Bureau of Investigation and the FBI are still examining whether any laws were violated by Dan J. Sullivan’s recruitment as a candidate.

Democrat Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race, defeating Republican Dan Sullivan — Associated Press