More than 200 subpoenas have been issued in a federal criminal investigation examining whether Democratic operatives recruited a second Dan Sullivan to run for Alaska’s U.S. Senate seat, Fox News reported Wednesday, citing law enforcement sources.
The scope of the probe became clear after Democrat Mary Peltola was declared the winner of the four-way race Tuesday night — two weeks after Election Day. She defeated incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan by 144,302 votes to 131,844, a margin of 12,458 votes, according to results confirmed by the Washington Examiner. The spoiler candidate, Dan J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher from Petersburg, received 4,760 first-choice votes, while Republican Gerald Heikes took 6,105.
“The criminal case is continuing, and that Peltola being named the winner doesn’t change anything from an investigative standpoint,” a law enforcement source told Fox News. The investigation spans multiple states and involves multiple criminal targets, the source said. A second source confirmed the subpoena count to the network.
High-profile Democratic elections attorney Marc Elias, whose firm represents the Peltola campaign, is among those who received a criminal target letter from the Justice Department earlier this month, Fox News reported. According to the Washington Examiner, the DOJ sent more than 20 target and document preservation letters, including requests to third parties to retain records.

The controversy erupted days before the Nov. 3 election when The New York Times reported that Peltola campaign aides, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, and political operatives outside Alaska participated in what they called a “ballot composition project” aimed at recruiting a second Dan Sullivan to enter the race. Peltola’s campaign and the DSCC have denied any wrongdoing.
“You had the Democrat Party headed up by Elias, their lawyer, who was a bad guy, very bad guy — should go to jail, in my opinion,” President Donald Trump said on “Fox & Friends” on Election Day. “But you had the Democrat Party look all over Alaska for somebody named Sullivan.”
Dan J. Sullivan Jr. kept a notably low profile during the campaign. Neighbors in Petersburg reported never seeing campaign materials from him, and his campaign raised just $35,556, Fox News reported. The Washington Examiner added that the candidate left his hometown the week before Election Day; a former student told CBS News she saw him on an Oct. 26 flight to Anchorage, two days before the Times published its report.
Alaska election officials initially moved to remove the second Sullivan from the ballot, arguing his candidacy was intended to confuse voters. The candidate denied wrongdoing, and the Alaska Supreme Court ruled he could remain on the ballot, Fox News reported. The DOJ then sued in October to mitigate any “misleading” impact, asking a federal court to set aside ballots ranking the challenger to determine whether voters confused the two candidates.
U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason, an appointee of former President Barack Obama, dismissed the lawsuit on Nov. 1 for lack of standing after finding the DOJ had offered no workable remedy, the Washington Examiner reported. The department appealed the same day.
However, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has set a briefing schedule that puts the DOJ’s opening brief due Dec. 14 — nearly three weeks after Alaska’s target certification date of Nov. 25 and eight days before the new Congress is sworn in on Jan. 3.
“That’s why you need to preserve the ballots because you need to look at the individual ballots, potentially, to see if there was voter confusion,” Attorney General Todd Blanche said on Fox News on Nov. 3. He said investigators could examine ballots for indications that voters meant to back the incumbent.

The appeal itself does not block the state from certifying the results, the Washington Examiner noted. Neither Peltola nor Sullivan’s campaigns returned comment requests, and neither did the DSCC. The White House deferred to the president’s earlier comments.
| Candidate | Party | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Mary Peltola | Democrat | 144,302 |
| Dan S. Sullivan | Republican (incumbent) | 131,844 |
| Gerald Heikes | Republican | 6,105 |
| Dan J. Sullivan Jr. | Non-party affiliated | 4,760 |
Alaska uses ranked-choice voting. Peltola crossed 50% of the vote in the unofficial count, prompting the Associated Press to call the race Tuesday, the Washington Examiner reported.