Eastern Oregon governments are taking Governor Tina Kotek to court over a pause on data center permits, arguing the move threatens billions in investment, opb reported.
The City of Umatilla and Umatilla County filed a petition in Umatilla County Circuit Court on November 11 asking a judge to compel the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality to resume processing air and water pollution permits for new or expanding data centers. Kotek directed DEQ Director Leah Feldon on October 9 to halt that work until July 1, 2027, following her September call for a statewide moratorium on the industry.
The petition frames the governor’s order as a “categorical suspension” of DEQ rules without the required rulemaking to amend or repeal them. Attorneys for the city and county contend the agency has a mandatory, nondiscretionary duty to evaluate National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System applications on their merits, not freeze an entire industry.

The financial stakes are staggering. Umatilla officials declared a local emergency over “financial loss” on October 20, estimating the pause would cost the city $2.5 million in annual tax payments and $12 million in developer-funded water infrastructure improvements. The November court filing expands that picture: the county and city say they face more than $6 million in direct financial losses, millions more in delayed enterprise zone revenues, and a threat to bonding for a $19.8 million police station approved by voters.
The petition warns the suspension risks driving away “more than $1.2 billion in additional private investment that is actively being negotiated.” Apple Valley News Now cites even larger figures from city officials: more than $5 billion in anticipated industrial investment and at least 1,000 construction jobs.
DEQ spokesperson Antony Sparrow would not comment on the petition but confirmed the agency keeps working on draft permits until they reach the public comment stage, after which it follows the governor’s order and stops.
While Umatilla fights the pause in court, a parallel transparency fight is unfolding. The La Grande–based nonprofit Oregon Rural Action announced Tuesday that public records requests revealed nondisclosure agreements between Amazon and at least nine local governments in Umatilla and Morrow counties — including the City of Umatilla and Umatilla County. The NDAs self-renew on three-year cycles and remain in effect for five years after termination, the group said.
“Look, this is proof of what we already knew: that the data center boom here is built on a foundation of secrecy.”
said Hermiston resident Becky Davison in a statement released by Oregon Rural Action. “We have serious questions about how much water data centers are using, how contaminated their wastewater is and where it goes, and Amazon is using NDAs to hide the answers from the public.”
The nonprofit pointed to a 2017 email in which an Amazon representative refused to give wastewater data to Hermiston City Manager Byron Smith unless the city signed an NDA. Amazon committed last month to stop using such agreements with local governments and said it is working toward terminating existing ones, but the Eastern Oregon deals predate that pledge. Amazon did not respond to a request for comment from Focal News.

The controversy has not deterred neighboring communities. The city of Irrigon, population roughly 2,000 and situated between data center hubs in Boardman and Umatilla, recently commissioned an economic analysis recommending opening hundreds of acres to data center development.
Data centers have become a flashpoint in Oregon politics. Recent survey data shows broad unpopularity among voters, driven by concerns over energy consumption, water use, and environmental footprint. Kotek’s moratorium and permit pause reflect that sentiment, but local officials in Umatilla argue the industry has funded critical infrastructure while keeping residential water rates competitive. The court petition is expected to be heard in the coming weeks.