Maui Police Commission Keeps Chief Pelletier on Leave, Expands Investigation

The Maui Police Commission voted 6-1 Wednesday to keep Chief John Pelletier on paid administrative leave, rejecting his attorney’s demand for reinstatement and expanding an outside investigation into his oversight of a now-dissolved unit led by a lieutenant facing federal bribery charges.

Commissioners acted after hearing roughly six hours of testimony from about 30 speakers, many of whom backed Pelletier, according to Civil Beat. The vote deepens a standoff that has engulfed the department since October, when the panel unanimously placed Pelletier on leave to review his supervision of the Criminal Intelligence Unit.

That unit reported directly to the chief and was commanded by Lt. Michael Vaituulala, who was arrested by federal authorities on allegations he accepted bribes and used his police powers to protect cockfight organizers, drug traffickers and illegal fireworks distributors. Pelletier has not been accused of personal wrongdoing.

“It supports public trust and accountability, and it preserves due process and fairness.”

Toni Rojas told Eric Seitz, Pelletier’s attorney, before the vote. “I saw this as a temporary measure. We’re helping protect the chief’s employment rights, his livelihood, while the facts are all being reviewed.”

Seitz, a Honolulu attorney, argued the leave amounted to discipline without due process and threatened litigation. “Then I won’t have to sue you,” he told commissioners after waiting hours to testify. After the meeting, he said a lawsuit had been drafted and would be filed within a week.

“They can’t just simply remove him as they’ve done on some ambiguous charges,” Seitz said. “They’ve got to state those charges. They’ve got to give him an opportunity to respond. They’ve got to conduct a hearing.”

Maui Police Commission Keeps Chief Pelletier on Leave, Expands Investigation
Photo: globeverge.com

Chair Frank Tam reiterated that the commission was not accusing Pelletier of misconduct. “All we’re saying is that it would be in the best interest of the investigation for him not to remain in place,” Tam said, citing guidance from corporation counsel that the action was appropriate.

The commission also voted to broaden the scope of an existing outside inquiry — initially focused on a high-profile property damage case — to include Pelletier’s role in the department’s response, and authorized a separate investigation into his public comments and conduct since being placed on leave.

Maui Police Commission Places Chief Pelletier on Leave — Akakū Maui Community Media

Two days after the October leave decision, Pelletier held a press conference alleging that Mayor Richard Bissen had been the subject of separate criminal investigations by the Hawaiʻi Attorney General’s Office and the Maui Police Department for months.

Pelletier claimed the mayor retaliated by influencing the commission’s vote, an accusation Bissen denied. Maui County Prosecutor Andrew Martin later said Bissen is not the subject of a state criminal investigation into allegations of fraud and financial mismanagement.

Testimony Wednesday split along familiar lines. Supporters described a chief committed to rooting out internal corruption. Critics countered that Pelletier had become overly defensive and reluctant to accept accountability for the unit that operated under his direct command.

The stalemate leaves the department under interim leadership while the expanded investigations proceed. Seitz’s promised lawsuit will test whether the commission’s authority to place a chief on paid leave pending an inquiry withstands a due-process challenge — a question with implications for police governance across the state.