Emily Bickford Asked U.S. Supreme Court to Hear Maine Custody Case

Emily Bickford, a Maine mother blocked from taking her 13-year-old daughter to church without the father’s permission, has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to hear her case.

The case centers on a 2013 parental rights agreement requiring both parents to consult on major decisions, including the child’s religious upbringing. Conflict grew in 2021 when Bickford began attending Calvary Chapel Greater Portland and brought her daughter to several services each week without initially informing Bradeen. Both parents subsequently sought sole authority over religious decisions.

The trial court found the child experienced anxiety and panic attacks tied to church teachings about hell and the Second Coming, and that she worried her father would be “left behind.” The court determined Bickford did not treat the anxiety as a problem that needed attention.

Fa emily bickford

The August 2024 Service

A pivotal moment came on August 28, 2024. Pastor Carey delivered a prayer of about six and a half minutes naming the parents and child almost 30 times, describing Bradeen as needing salvation and framing the legal dispute as an attack on God’s word. The court found Bickford knew the pastor planned to talk about the case and encouraged him. The child was present.

The trial court concluded such messages cast Bradeen as an enemy of his daughter’s faith, risking psychological harm and alienation. It also found Bickford planned a baptism and overnight church retreat without informing Bradeen.

State High Court Reasoning

The justices examined their 1980 decision in Osier v. Osier, which discussed requiring evidence of an immediate and substantial threat before restricting a parent’s religious practices.

The court held that judges may allocate religious decision-making based on the child’s best interests without always applying strict scrutiny. They also rejected Bickford’s claim that the trial court showed hostility toward religion.

Emily Bickford Asked U.S. Supreme Court to Hear Maine Custody Case

The Petition’s Argument

Liberty Counsel argues the order effectively allows Bradeen to stop Bickford from sharing her Christian faith during her own parenting time. The petition invokes Wisconsin v. Yoder, Troxel v. Granville, Mahmoud v. Taylor, and Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission, asking whether limits on a fit parent’s religious practices must meet strict scrutiny and whether the order demonstrates hostility toward Christian beliefs.

“The decision abandons the constitutional safeguards that protect parental rights and religious liberty.”

The Supreme Court has not decided whether it will hear the case.