Essentia Health will pay more than $10,000 to ten advanced practice providers and post a federal rights notice across its East Market facilities to settle retaliation charges stemming from last summer’s unfair labor practice strike, the Minnesota Nurses Association reported.
The National Labor Relations Board settlement resolves allegations that the Duluth-based health system punished nurse practitioners and physician assistants for joining the work stoppage by cutting off their access to open shifts — a move the union said amounted to retaliation for protected concerted activity.
Under the agreement, Essentia must mail, email and prominently display the official NLRB notice for 60 consecutive days to current and former APPs employed in the East Market since June 27, 2025.
“Essentia can call this a business decision, but 10 APPs are receiving compensation after raising retaliation concerns following a protected ULP strike,” said Sara McCumber, APRN, CNP at Essentia Health. “Healthcare workers should never have to worry that standing together for better working conditions will cost them opportunities to earn a living. Essentia owes its workers more than another memo denying responsibility.”
The health system disputes that characterization. In a November 2 memorandum to staff, Vice President of Labor Relations John Haberman framed the settlement as a pragmatic choice to avoid the time and expense of further litigation and maintained that Essentia had not engaged in retaliation.
The NLRB settlement explicitly bars the employer from posting any accompanying notices that attempt to minimize the official notice or suggest the health system disagrees with its statements.
“Essentia’s response to serious allegations of retaliation is to tell its employees that it did nothing wrong,” said Caitlin Campbell, NP at Essentia Health. “Meanwhile, they have agreed to compensation and to notify workers of their federally protected rights. Essentia’s leadership should spend less time defending its reputation and more time making sure workers can exercise those rights without fear.”
Essentia operates hospitals and clinics in Duluth and Virginia, Minnesota, and Superior, Wisconsin. The East Market covers facilities in Duluth and Virginia, Minnesota, and Superior, Wisconsin — the same communities where the strike unfolded last summer. The ten APPs who filed charges represent a fraction of the system’s advanced practice workforce, but the settlement’s reach extends to every current and former APP in the region since late June 2025.
The NLRB’s Region 18 office in Minneapolis handled the case. The board’s public docket shows the settlement was executed in late October, with the notice distribution beginning this month. No hearing or formal admission of liability was required; the agreement is a compromise that closes the docket while preserving the workers’ right to pursue further action if the terms are violated.
The union has argued that post-strike scheduling retaliation has become a quiet tactic across the industry — difficult to prove, but devastating to the workers targeted. The settlement, while modest in dollar terms, establishes a documented precedent that such restrictions can draw federal enforcement.