Ex-Mayor Knobe: SD Voters Back Progressive Measures, Elect Trump-Aligned Republicans

South Dakota voters have spent years approving ballot measures that raise the minimum wage, ban predatory lending, expand Medicaid and protect majority rule for constitutional amendments, yet they keep sending Republicans to Pierre and Washington who oppose those very policies.

Former Sioux Falls mayor and radio host Rick Knobe laid out the contradiction in a column published Thursday by The South Dakota Standard. He pointed to the 2024 cycle, where voters re-elected U.S. Sen. John Thune — who Knobe noted votes with Donald Trump roughly 99 percent of the time — returned a congressman photographed giving a thumbs-up beside Trump, and chose a governor who “bent his knee” to the former president.

Knobe argued the disconnect stems from four decades of messaging that casts every Democrat as a threat to guns and unborn children, a narrative he said has hardened into tribal reflex.

“All Republicans are good. All Democrats are bad, even evil,” he wrote. “For the record, I have never met anyone who wants to kill babies. I have not met a Democrat who wants to take away guns. Yet that lie persists.”

He recalled a conversation with a Republican acquaintance who opposed a citizen-led open-primary initiative because it would have removed party labels from the ballot. The man told Knobe he needed the “R” next to a name to know how to vote — no research, no weighing of positions. The measure failed.

Knobe arrived in Sioux Falls in 1971 from Sioux City to launch the call-in program “Your Opinion Please” at KCHF, a show that would anchor his broadcasting career for more than three decades. During his tenure he championed improvements to the city’s waterways and secured land for the bike trail system, work that remained a point of civic pride.

Rs win here because they have convinced themselves and too many of us that Rs are good, Ds are not, and Independents are spineless, with no core beliefs.

— Rick Knobe, former mayor of Sioux Falls

While Republicans lost ground nationally in 2024 — flipping the Senate, the House, several governorships and state legislative chambers — South Dakota’s supermajority held. Knobe cited the folk standard “Where Have All the Flowers Gone?” to frame the puzzle: “When will we ever learn? When will WE ever learn?”