FanGraphs Yankees Top 37 Prospects: High-Velocity Arms, Contact Questions Define Farm System

FanGraphs Baseball published its annual New York Yankees Top 37 Prospects list on Friday, offering a granular look at a farm system increasingly defined by pitching volatility and a search for impact bats.

The report, authored by Dax Kilby, marks the seventh year the outlet has split relief projections into multi-inning (MIRP) and single-inning (SIRP) roles, with ETAs tethered to Rule 5 draft eligibility deadlines. It paints a picture of an organization stockpiling high-velocity arms but struggling to convert raw stuff into reliable major-league outcomes.

The Reliever Periphery: High Spin, Low Certainty

Kilby groups six upper-level relievers — Michael Harpster, Zach Messinger, Hayden Merda, Carson Coleman, Eric Reyzelman, and Xavier Rivas — as candidates for a “cup of coffee” in 2027 who may struggle to stick. Harpster, a 2026 seventh-rounder out of East Tennessee State, draws the strongest praise: a quick arm with plus-plus spin on breaking stuff makes him the top candidate for a first-year pro breakout.

Video: FanGraphs

Messinger sits 95-96 mph but misses few bats, evolving into a cutter-heavy Triple-A reliever inducing weak contact; opponents hit .177 against him in 2026, though his walk and strikeout rates remain pedestrian.

Merda touches 96 with a killer cutter/slider combo but carries “fatal, 20-grade control,” per the report. Coleman’s career arc illustrates the fragility of a one-pitch profile: he struck out 36-38% of hitters in 2021-2022 with an uphill mid-90s fastball thrown 75-90% of the time, but injuries wiped out nearly three years, and he has never developed a reliable secondary offering.

Reyzelman’s trajectory is the most dramatic. He looked ticketed for the big-league bullpen in 2024 after fanning 14.27 per nine at Double-A. A peanut allergy hospitalization during 2025 spring training derailed him; his fastball dropped three ticks, and a dominant first two months in 2026 gave way to a walk-prone second half after an IL stint.

Rivas profiles as a smoke-and-mirrors lefty sitting 90 mph with nasty secondary stuff and a strikeout-per-inning track record since college, but extreme walk rates cloud his projection.

York yankees prospects
Photo: khanlist.com

Power Hitters Show Pop but Struggle with Contact

On the position-player side, Kilby identifies a “Power Hitters” cluster — Jackson Lovich, Garrett Martin, Jace Avina, Kyle West, and Queni Pineda — united by raw pop but plagued by swing-and-miss or approach concerns. Lovich, a 22-year-old, 6-foot-3 third baseman from Missouri, shows plus projected power and the best defensive fit of the group, yet his chase rates at Low-A Tampa temper excitement for a former SEC hitter.

Martin forced a 40-man roster addition this week after 24 homers in 71 games, mostly as a 26-year-old repeating Double-A. He averages 20 degrees of launch angle with 70-grade peak exit velocities, but Kilby calls his feel to hit “pretty bad,” noting he surrenders the outer half to pull everything.

Avina, acquired from Milwaukee in the Jake Bauers deal, hit 21 homers at Double-A Somerset at age 23, geared for extreme launch. West, a 2025 13th-rounder, pairs plus-plus low-ball power with a 30% strikeout rate and an 81 wRC+ in 2026. Pineda, a 19-year-old catcher, saw his contact rate plummet from 74% to 69% against Florida Complex League pitching.

Traded and International Arms Add Organizational Depth

The “Cambios Buenos” section highlights arms acquired via trade or late international signing. Sean Paul Liñan — originally a Dodger, then a National (Alex Call trade), now a Yankee (Jorbit Vivas trade) — is a changeup artist with an 89 mph fastball who dominated Low-A in 2024-2025 but lacked the velocity or breaking ball to sustain it at High-A. Luis Serna, once a precocious 16-year-old in the DSL, missed chunks of 2023 and 2025 to injury; he pitched well at High-A Hudson Valley in 2026 but remains an undersized righty sitting 91-92 reliant on his changeup.

Jose M. Rodriguez throws 95 with a tailing changeup but has chronic 20-grade control. Pico Kohn, a 2025 fourth-rounder, sits 91 with an above-average slider from a high arm slot and could profile as a lefty specialist after returning from a leg stress reaction.

Three FCL arms — Edinzo Marquez, Enixon Sanchez, and Manuel Cruz — each touch 97 but carry severe command issues. Marquez, 21, earned a mid-season promotion to Low-A Tampa before velocity dipped. Sanchez (19) and Cruz (20) walked 15-20% of batters faced.

The Yankees’ undrafted free-agent haul reads like a development laboratory. Zach Johnston, a sidearming lefty from Wake Forest with a good curveball, profiles as a specialist. J.T. Etheridge, a 6-foot-6 lower-slot righty from Louisiana-Lafayette, shows a tough-on-righties delivery and changeup flashes. Easton Talt, an Oregon State outfielder, is the group’s best pure contact hitter.

Eric Genther, 24, doesn’t throw well enough to catch but hit for power at High-A as an older player. Maika Niu (Arkansas) and Jorsixt Jimenez (Tennessee Tech) offer raw power with severe swing deficiencies. Trent Sellers, 27, has a hoppy 92 mph fastball and funky changeup at Double-A. Matthew Tippie’s slider dominated Low-A hitters in relief.

Rehabbing Pitchers Target 2027 Return to Prospect Lists

Formerly well-regarded arms Brock Selvidge, Sabier Marte, and Chalniel Arias sit in limbo. Selvidge, recovering from pinched nerve surgery and an internal brace, threw three ticks harder in 2026 spring training; if that holds in 2027, he re-enters the main list conversation.

Marte, a 6-foot-5, 22-year-old touching 97, finally escaped rookie ball in 2026 after missing 2025 but struggled. Arias, once a DSL standout with a projectable 6-foot-3 frame, returned from surgery in 2026 for two starts at 92-94 mph.

Chien-Fan Lai, an athletic Taiwanese righty, sat 90-93 with a mid-70s curveball for Taiwan’s U18 team. Hector Moreno, 6-foot-6 with a plus-flashing slider at 94-98, walks more than a batter per inning.

Osveiker Chirino touched 95 in three DSL innings at 17. Cesar Acosta, 20, sits up to 96 with a gyro slider and improved command in his second DSL season. Jhon Beltre, 18, hit 96 with a flashy breaking ball but remains too wild for the main list.

FanGraphs Baseball, created and owned by David Appelman and based in Arlington, Virginia, has supplied public sabermetric data for every Major League Baseball player in history since its founding. The outlet began publishing its annual fantasy companion book and, in 2017, absorbed the thrice-weekly podcast Effectively Wild from Baseball Prospectus, expanding its reach beyond written analysis into audio.

The next inflection point arrives in 2027, when Rule 5 protection decisions force the Yankees to separate lottery tickets from legitimate assets. Injuries will likely give us the opportunity to find out.