Annie Anderson, 53, pleaded guilty Friday to negligent homicide in the 2005 death of her newborn daughter, abandoning a first-degree murder charge that could have sent her to prison for life, AZFamily reported.
The plea agreement, entered in Maricopa County Superior Court, dismisses the original first-degree murder charge. Anderson was arrested in Washington state in 2024 and extradited to Arizona that year. She heard the charges at her first court appearance in Maricopa County in April 2024 and pleaded not guilty at her arraignment days later.
The plea agreement, entered during a settlement conference before Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Amy Kalman, caps any potential prison term at 3.75 years and leaves probation — with up to a year in jail — on the table. Sentencing is set for Feb. 5, 2027.
Anderson remains free on electronic monitoring after posting a $200,000 bond in December with help from a reproductive justice group, ABC15 reported. Court documents show Anderson posted the $200,000 bond on December 11. The other charges Anderson was facing will be dismissed under the plea offer.
“When confronted, Annie Anderson identified herself as the mother of the victim and provided an account of what occurred,” Lt. James Hester of the Phoenix Police Department said at the time of her arrest.

Anderson had been in town for a real estate boot camp. The case went cold for 17 years until investigators with the Phoenix Police Department and the FBI’s Violent Crimes Task Force used investigative genetic genealogy to identify a maternal match, The Phoenix Focal reported. Detectives tracked Anderson to Washington state in 2022.
Detectives tracked Anderson to Washington state in 2022. Court documents say she told them she gave birth in a hotel bathtub and that the baby was stillborn. The medical examiner determined the infant had lived for 24 hours, and the manner of death was later changed from homicide to undetermined after a 2022 review. Prosecutors acknowledged Friday that a trial would have become a “battle of the experts,” ABC15 reported.
According to arrest paperwork, Anderson allegedly told police she gave birth in her hotel bathtub and claimed the baby was stillborn, which police said is inconsistent with evidence and information from the medical examiner. Police also used DNA to identify the baby’s biological father, who told police he didn’t know Anderson was pregnant.
“The judge said this is considered a domestic violence offense,” ABC15 noted from the hearing. If Anderson receives a prison sentence, she will get credit for time served; jail time under probation may not carry the same credit.
Investigators on the original case chipped in their own funds to purchase a headstone for the infant, a gesture that has come to represent the department’s enduring dedication, The Phoenix Focal reported.
The outcome underscores how genetic genealogy is increasingly solving cold cases that once appeared unsolvable, even as the reduced charge and potential for probation may revive debate over how the legal system treats deaths of the most vulnerable.
Anderson’s sentencing is set for Feb. 5, 2027.