A federal judge in Eugene ruled Friday that ICE officers violated the law when they seized a 56-year-old Albany man outside a Walmart on June 18, exposing a dragnet operation that targeted shoppers at big-box stores with “no rhyme or reason.”
U.S. District Judge Mustafa T. Kasubhai found the arrest unlawful because officers never served a valid warrant on the man, identified in court filings as L.A.M.A., and failed to assess whether he posed a flight risk before taking him into custody.
The Supermarket Stakeout
“Let’s hit Albany / Dallas,” a Portland-based supervisory detention-and-deportation officer identified as D.B. wrote to his team on the morning of June 18. He sent the addresses of two Walmarts — one in Albany, the other in Dallas, Oregon — describing them as “landmarks” to start the shift, according to testimony read in court.
Officers were not looking for a specific person slated for deportation. They were randomly running license plates of shoppers in the parking lots of Walmart, Safeway and Fred Meyer stores, D.B. acknowledged on the stand. When attorney Stephen Manning of the nonprofit Innovation Law Lab asked whether the cities were chosen for their Latino, working-class immigrant populations, D.B. said no. Kasubhai pressed further.
“So, the only reason you picked a Walmart is because it opened early?” Kasubhai asked. D.B. testified that Walmart opens early and that shifts usually start early, adding that officers run plates at grocery store parking lots because “we’re looking to arrest people and that’s where people are mobile.”
Kasubhai noted he had not heard of ICE conducting similar operations at Whole Foods Market or Bridgeport Village, an upscale shopping center.
A Life Upended in the Parking Lot
L.A.M.A., whose first language is Mayan, testified through an interpreter that he has lived in Oregon for 35 years. He owns a pallet-repair business, employs three workers, pays taxes, and has four children. He entered the United States in 1991 fleeing violence in Mexico and has a pending immigration case, with a hearing scheduled for February challenging his removal.
Around 10:30 a.m., after buying water and bread for his work crew, he walked back to his pickup truck. ICE officers took him into custody, drove him to Portland’s ICE facility, then to the Tacoma area, and later dropped him in Portland — roughly 70 miles from his home and his vehicle.
The government claimed officers had a digital copy of the warrant, but Kasubhai found no record it was ever served, read to the man, or dated.
“The arrest itself is unlawful,” Kasubhai said from the bench. He called L.A.M.A. the “most credible witness” to testify about the events of that day.
A Pattern of ‘Sloppy Work’ and False Reports
Friday’s ruling sits alongside a broader rebuke Kasubhai issued Monday in a related class-action case brought by Innovation Law Lab. In that order, the judge found ICE officers in Oregon have continued making warrantless arrests in violation of a February preliminary injunction that barred such arrests unless the person is likely to flee.

Kasubhai was particularly scathing about an ICE deportation officer identified as J.G., who testified in September that he fabricated details in an official arrest report, known as an I-213, for a July arrest in Medford. The officer attested he knew the detainee’s immigration status before the stop; on the stand, he admitted that was false.
“It defies logic that such consequential errors in the I-213 form are merely a ‘mistake,'” Kasubhai wrote. “The Court finds that he did not make a mistake in the I-213. He lied in an official record to facilitate the impression he was conducting a lawful warrant-based arrest.”
The judge also found widespread use of boilerplate language in arrest reports, including identical claims that officers were “unaware” of community ties — language Kasubhai wrote was a “clear example of their failure to conduct simple law enforcement investigative duties” and called “sloppy work.” Kasubhai also wrote that the Court finds ICE officers conducted significantly more than 13 warrantless arrests in Oregon between February 2026 and August 2026.
Kasubhai ordered ICE to produce all arrest documents and body-worn camera footage for arrests on or after September 1 to Innovation Law Lab. He also ordered officers not to “abandon” people they release miles from home, but to return them to their vehicles or hometowns.
Kasubhai to Hold Hearings and Call Federal Officers in Habeas Cases
Kasubhai said he will schedule evidentiary hearings and call federal officers to testify in every habeas petition assigned to him that challenges an immigration detention as unlawful. “I’ll continue to do that until someone tells me I can’t,” he said. A written opinion in L.A.M.A.’s case is forthcoming.
Whether the June 18 operation was racially motivated will be litigated in the separate class-action suit, where Kasubhai has already ordered ICE officers in Oregon to stop making warrantless arrests. “It’s not lost on me what and how ICE is targeting certain communities, neighborhoods with a very identifiable Latino community,” the judge said Friday.
Mustafa T. Kasubhai, born in 1970 in the Los Angeles suburb of Reseda to Gujarati Dawoodi Bohra immigrants from Mumbai, became the first Muslim to serve as a federal judge in the United States when he was appointed a magistrate judge for the District of Oregon in 2018.
He previously served on the Lane County Circuit Court from 2007 to 2018, also as the first South Asian-American and Muslim judge on that court, and received his district judge commission on November 22, 2024.
The federal government has denied the class-action allegations. ICE did not immediately respond to requests for comment Monday.