Federal Jury Acquits Rio Grande Restaurant Owner, Son on All 12 Immigration Charges

A federal jury in Charleston acquitted Miguel Aguirre-Arello and his son Miguel Angel Aguirre on all 12 immigration charges Thursday after a few hours of deliberation.

A federal jury in Charleston needed just a few hours Thursday to hand Miguel Aguirre-Arello and his son Miguel Angel Aguirre a clean slate, acquitting both men on all twelve counts stemming from the January ICE raid on their Nitro restaurant.

The verdict, returned in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia, caps a prosecution that began with a superseding indictment filed March 17 charging the father and son with four counts each of making false statements on Form I-9 employment documents and four counts each of harboring immigrants for financial gain.

Jurors rejected every count, delivering a unanimous verdict that defense attorneys Ryan Donovan, Andrew Tessman and Maureen Gleason called a rejection of the government’s entire case.

“The federal government devoted extraordinary resources to investigating and prosecuting a family-owned Mexican restaurant in Nitro, West Virginia,” the attorneys from Hissam Forman Donovan Ritchie said in a statement. “But after hearing the evidence, the jury unanimously rejected all 12 charges against the two defendants.”

Federal agents descended on the Rio Grande Mexican Restaurant on January 16 as part of Operation Country Roads, a statewide enforcement sweep that yielded 650 arrests over 15 days. The Nitro operation alone resulted in immigration-related charges for eight people, though the charges against the Aguirre family were the most serious, carrying potential forfeiture of property tied to the alleged harboring offenses.

Federal Jury Acquits Rio Grande Restaurant Owner, Son on All 12 Immigration Charges
Photo: wchstv.com

Prosecutors alleged the conduct spanned from June 2025 through January 2026, focusing on employment eligibility forms for four workers and allegations that the defendants concealed three individuals at the restaurant and, in three instances, at a residence. Court records show the government pursued an aiding-and-abetting theory on every count, arguing father and son worked in concert.

The case unfolded against a backdrop of guilty pleas by several restaurant workers earlier this year. Rosmery Morales-Mejia and Rufino Hernandez pleaded to document-fraud charges, while Pablo Dominguez admitted to illegal reentry after removal, according to federal prosecutors’ announcements. Those proceedings were handled separately from the trial of the owner and his son, a distinction the defense emphasized in arguing the government’s burden of proof.

WCHS-TV reported the jury specifically found the father and son did not knowingly accept or falsify documents and did not illegally conceal anyone from law enforcement. The station noted the verdicts came Thursday, aligning with the federal court docket for case number 2:26-cr-00010.

“This case is an important reminder that suspicion is not proof, that the government bears the burden of proving criminal wrongdoing beyond a reasonable doubt, and that working hard to support a family business is not a crime,” the defense team said in their statement.

Neither the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of West Virginia nor ICE has commented publicly on the verdict as of Thursday afternoon.