IPS Proposes Closing Six Schools Amid $20M Budget Gap, Declining Enrollment

Indianapolis Public Schools is proposing to close six buildings after this school year to address a $20 million budget gap for next school year.

Indianapolis Public Schools is proposing to close six buildings after this school year, a move that would displace students for the second time in four years at two of the campuses.

The plan, presented to the school board at a Tuesday agenda review session and reported by The 74, targets Frederick Douglass School 19, Ralph Waldo Emerson School 58, Merle Sidener Academy 59, Robert Lee Frost School 106, Longfellow Middle School and the Margaret McFarland Learning Academy and Positive Supports Academy. The board is expected to vote on the recommendations on Dec. 8.

Superintendent Aleesia Johnson framed the decision as a financial necessity. Even with the roughly $42.5 million the district will receive from an operating referendum voters approved on Nov. 3, IPS faces a $20 million budget gap for next school year, Axios reported. The closures are projected to save about $4 million.

“There is no doubt that leaving behind a school community you love brings challenges and a lot of emotion,” Johnson said. “Even while knowing how hard these changes can be, we will get through this the way we always have — with a focus on our kids and ensuring we create the best conditions for their success.”

The district has lost roughly a third of its enrollment over the past decade, dropping below 20,000 students, while combined enrollment in independent charters and Innovation Network schools now exceeds enrollment in IPS-run schools. Declining birth rates, expanded private school vouchers and charter growth have accelerated the exodus, taking per-pupil funding with each departing student.

Indianapolis public schools ips building sign
Photo: insideindianabusiness.com

The Merger Map

Under the proposal, students would be reassigned to receiving schools that maintain specific instructional models:

  • Ralph Waldo Emerson School 58 merges into Christian Park School 82, keeping the Exploratory model.
  • Robert Lee Frost School 106 merges into Eliza Blaker School 55, keeping the Reggio-inspired model.
  • Benjamin Harrison School 2 merges into Charity Dye School 27, keeping the International Baccalaureate model.
  • Longfellow Middle School merges into Howe Middle School, keeping the IB model.
  • Frederick Douglass School 19 and James A. Garfield School 31 both merge into Eleanor Skillen School 34, which will offer the STEM model currently at Garfield.
  • Margaret McFarland Learning Academy and Positive Supports Academy move to the Garfield School 31 building.
  • The elementary high-ability program moves from Merle Sidener Academy 59 to the Benjamin Harrison School 2 building, which Johnson described as more centrally located.
  • The new Joyce Kilmer 69 building under construction becomes the CITY Career Center.

Enrollment zones and grade configurations would stay intact, and families could choose a different school within their zone and still receive transportation, Johnson said. The first round of enrollment for the 2027-28 school year closes Dec. 18.

A Compressed Timeline and a Looming Deadline

The process differs sharply from the 2023 Rebuilding Stronger plan, which followed months of public input before the board closed six schools. This time, the district is moving on a compressed schedule driven by a structural deadline: in 2028, the newly formed Indianapolis Public Education Corporation will assume control of facilities and transportation for IPS and participating charter schools within the district’s boundaries.

Johnson said the district has a brief window to sell the closed buildings while it still controls them and before the state’s $1 building law — which requires districts to offer unused schools to charter schools for $1 — applies to IPS. The sale of those properties would generate revenue the district says it needs.

Frederick Douglass School 19 and Robert Lee Frost School 106 both absorbed students from schools closed in 2023. Those communities now face displacement again.

Superintendent Aleesia Johnson, a native of Evansville, Indiana, became the first Black woman to lead Indianapolis Public Schools when she was named superintendent in 2019. Her career spans more than two decades across both public charter and traditional district schools, including roles as a teacher, school leader, and administrator.

Before returning to Indiana, Johnson earned a Bachelor of Arts in Psychology and African-American Studies from Agnes Scott College and a Master of Social Work from the University of Michigan.

She later completed a Master of Arts in Teaching and a Doctorate of Education in Educational Leadership at Oakland City University. She currently serves on the Executive Committee of the Council of the Great City Schools and the board of Chiefs for Change.

IPS administration will publicly present the proposed moves to the board Thursday night. The board will vote Dec. 8.