Federal Report: 46% of Kentucky Kindergartners Ready for 2024-25 School Year

Fewer than half of Kentucky kindergartners started the 2024-25 school year meeting the state’s readiness benchmarks, a federal analysis released Nov. 12 shows.

A U.S. Government Accountability Office examination of state data found 46% of Kentucky students met the overall standard, with 60% of districts reporting readiness rates below 50%, Spectrum News reported. Only Fort Thomas Independent and Carlisle County topped 75%.

The GAO analyzed entry-assessment data from five states — Connecticut, Florida, Kentucky, Maryland and Ohio — in its second report on kindergarten readiness. The first, issued in 2024, reviewed how states collect and use such information.

Because each state uses different assessments and benchmarks, the GAO cautioned against cross-state comparisons, said Jackie Nowicki, the GAO director who oversaw the report. The five states were selected because they had publicly available data reliable enough to analyze, and there is no federal requirement that states assess kindergarten readiness.

“What we found was that less than 50% of kids are considered to be kindergarten ready,” Nowicki told Spectrum News. “That means that of all the kids about to go into kindergarten, they took whatever Kentucky’s assessment is for readiness, and less than half of them scored as being ready for kindergarten according to Kentucky state standards.”

Nowicki described readiness in plain terms: “Can you show up in your kindergarten classroom, and are you ready to be able to learn your ABCs and one, two, threes and behave like a good human?” Kentucky’s results varied significantly by district and by community type.

Kentucky measures readiness with the Brigance Early Childhood Kindergarten Screen III, which assesses five developmental areas. Statewide rates by domain were: social-emotional development 75%, physical and motor skills 43%, and academic and cognitive skills 32%, according to Lane Report. Academic and cognitive skills — recognizing letters, numbers and shapes — represented the largest gap.

Photo: yournews.com

Readiness varied by community type. Suburban districts posted higher rates than urban or rural districts, the GAO found. Higher preschool enrollment was associated with higher readiness rates in Kentucky and two other states, while higher poverty levels were associated with lower readiness. Girls were more likely than boys to meet the standards. Asian and White students generally met benchmarks more frequently than other demographic groups.

“Our work does not say that these various factors caused children to be ready for kindergarten,” Nowicki said. The data also do not explain why Fort Thomas Independent and Carlisle County outperformed other districts.

“Why is Fort Thomas Independent and Carlisle school districts scoring with 75% or more of their kids ready, while 60% of school districts in Kentucky have less than 50% of their kids ready?” Nowicki said. “That’s exactly the question that I would ask.”

Separate national research cited by Archway Academy found that among students entering kindergarten in the bottom 20% academically, only 10.3% achieved math proficiency and 13.9% achieved reading proficiency by third grade, Lane Report reported.

The GAO reviewed 11 peer-reviewed studies on publicly funded preschool; 10 found positive associations with kindergarten literacy, and seven found positive associations with math readiness, yourNEWS reported. Districts with higher public or private preschool enrollment tended to show higher readiness in Connecticut, Kentucky and Ohio. No statistically significant relationship was found in Florida or Maryland.

“Academic skills matter, but a child also has to be ready to participate in the school day. If they can manage those routines and work with other children, they are better prepared to focus on learning,” said Tami Nix, president of Archway Academy, an early-childhood education organization, to Lane Report.

States use different assessment methods: Connecticut relies primarily on teacher observations, Florida uses computer-based assessments, and Kentucky, Maryland and Ohio use combinations of observations, direct questions and other methods.

The full GAO report is available at gao.gov.