Feds Admit Austin Man Deported to Mexico Is US Citizen While Seeking Lawsuit Dismissal

The Trump administration acknowledged in federal court Friday that an Austin man it deported to Mexico in April is a United States citizen, reversing its previous insistence that he was in the country illegally.

The admission came in a motion asking a judge to dismiss the man’s lawsuit.

Brian José Morales García, 25, was born in Denver and holds dual citizenship with Mexico, U.S. Attorney Justin R. Simmons wrote in a filing before U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman in Austin.

The concession arrives nearly seven months after Border Patrol agents sent him across the border despite his repeated claims that he was American. “CBP did NOT arrest a U.S. citizen,” a Customs and Border Protection spokesperson told the Texas Tribune in April. “Agents determined Morales García was illegally in the U.S. through record checks.”

The case began April 3 when a Texas Department of Public Safety trooper stopped a pickup truck near Fredericksburg for an alleged window-tint violation. He was not carrying identification. Local officers contacted federal immigration agents, who took him to the Gillespie County Jail. Four days later, he was removed to Mexico.

Feds Admit Austin Man Deported to Mexico Is US Citizen While Seeking Lawsuit Dismissal
Photo: fox26houston.com

The government’s version of events

Federal attorneys say Border Patrol Agent Robert Gil Jr. questioned Morales García at the jail and checked a Mexican government database after Morales García said he did not have his birth certificate. The agent found a Mexican registration record listing a birthplace in Zacatecas, Mexico.

According to the motion, Gil warned Morales García that providing false information could bring criminal charges, and Morales García then said he was born in Mexico. Based on that record and statement, Gil concluded he was in the United States illegally.

The government contends Gil explained Morales García’s options — appearing before an immigration judge or voluntarily returning to Mexico — and that Morales García chose to return, signing forms confirming the decision. Federal attorneys deny he was threatened or coerced.

Morales García’s account differs sharply

In his lawsuit, filed May 1, Morales García alleges agents repeatedly accused him of lying about his citizenship and threatened him with imprisonment.

An Austin man’s deportation case is back in federal court after the Trump administration acknowledged his dual U.S.-Mexican
Photo: svtoday.org

Morales García’s mother, María del Socorro García, previously told the Texas Tribune the family moved from Mexico to Denver in 1999. She returned to Mexico with her sons in 2002 so they could meet their grandfather, who was struggling with diabetes.

In January 2025, Morales García reentered the United States legally through the El Paso port of entry, presenting his birth certificate to CBP officers, he told the Tribune.

Judge declines order cites conflicting birth records

The judge directed both sides to gather additional evidence. Morales García’s attorneys subsequently obtained hospital records and witness statements before the federal government agreed to permit his return on August 30 — nearly five months after his removal. The latest motion does not explain what specific evidence ultimately resolved the conflicting records or whether immigration authorities reviewed that evidence before allowing him back.

Justice department argues immunity bars damages suit

Despite acknowledging his citizenship, the Justice Department argues Morales García cannot pursue damages against individual immigration agents under the Bivens doctrine, which allows certain lawsuits against federal officers for constitutional violations.

The government contends federal courts have declined to extend those protections to claims involving civil immigration enforcement. It also argues sovereign immunity bars his claims against federal officials in their official capacities because he has not shown the government waived that immunity.

Separately, Gillespie County Chief Deputy Bryan Philips moved Friday to dismiss any claims against him, arguing he was never named as a defendant and the complaint does not allege he personally participated in the detention. Judge Pitman has not ruled on either motion. Attorneys for Morales García did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the government’s filing, the Austin American-Statesman reported.

The lawsuit seeks compensation for detention, removal, lost wages and emotional distress.