First Court of Appeals Dismisses Houston Federation of Teachers Lawsuit Over Retention Allotment

A Texas appeals court has cleared the way for Houston ISD to spend state retention money on performance bonuses instead of across-the-board raises, handing Superintendent Mike Miles a procedural victory that leaves the underlying legal fight unresolved.

The First Court of Appeals dismissed the Houston Federation of Teachers’ lawsuit on Tuesday, ruling the union skipped the required administrative grievance process before heading to court. The decision vacates a temporary injunction that had blocked the district from redirecting the Teacher Retention Allotment — money the Legislature earmarked for veteran teachers — into its new pay-for-performance model, Houston Public Media reported.

The ruling does not decide whether HISD’s plan complies with House Bill 2. It only says the union must exhaust its remedies through the district and, if necessary, the Texas Education Commissioner before a court can weigh in.

(10-29-2026) Case No. 01-25-00830-CV Mike Miles; et al. v. Houston Federation of Teacher, local 2415 — Texas First Court of Appeals

“A procedural defeat is not a vindication of HISD’s decisions,” Brad Wray, an executive board member for the Houston Federation of Teachers, told Houston Public Media. “A court ruling can dismiss a lawsuit. It cannot erase the legislature’s commitment to teachers, silence the voices of educators, or eliminate our responsibility to fight for what is right.”

The money at stake

House Bill 2 created the Teacher Retention Allotment to deliver raises of $2,500 to $5,000 for classroom teachers with at least three years of experience, scaling up with tenure. In districts the size of HISD — the largest in the state — teachers with five or more years were in line for the top tier.

Neighboring districts including Cy-Fair, Fort Bend and Katy ISD distributed the money along those experience-based lines. HISD, under state-appointed leadership, chose a different path: it folded the allotment into a compensation system that ties every dollar of a teacher’s salary to evaluation ratings.

First Court of Appeals Dismisses Houston Federation of Teachers Lawsuit Over Retention Allotment
Photo: houstonchronicle.com

District cites exemption for performance payments

The district argues a statutory exemption allows it to distribute retention payments based on performance if it applies to become an Enhanced Teacher Incentive Allotment District. HISD’s outside attorney, Paul Lamp, told the appeals court in October that the union’s lawsuit was a “premature filing” because the administrative process had not run its course.

The union contends HISD never met the prerequisites for that enhanced status, making the carve-out inapplicable. In June 2025, the district announced it would distribute the money by performance. The union sued in July and won a partial injunction in August, pausing the payout while the case proceeded. Tuesday’s ruling lifts that pause.

What changes for teachers now

With the injunction lifted, HISD can move forward with performance-based payments of up to $2,500 from the retention allotment. The total pool of money involved has not been publicly specified. Teachers who expected experience-based raises — the model the Legislature wrote into HB 2 — will instead see compensation determined by the district’s evaluation rubric.

HFT President Jackie Anderson framed the stakes in blunt terms.

“Mike Miles decided to play games with educators’ livelihoods at a time when they and their families need relief the most,” Anderson said in a statement. “The rising cost of living is burying working families, and Texas still faces an educator shortage. That’s what the Teacher Retention Allotment was painstakingly crafted to address.”

The union pointed to Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa, who has pledged to end state takeovers and told The Texas Tribune she is “not a big fan of the Teacher Incentive Allotment” and wants to transition away from it.

First Court of Appeals Dismisses Houston Federation of Teachers Lawsuit Over Retention Allotment
Photo: thepineypoint.com

Anderson said the union’s immediate next step is filing grievances through the district’s internal process, with a potential appeal to the Education Commissioner if those are denied. The union also plans to push for compliance once a democratically elected board regains authority.

“We filed this lawsuit to stop the district from burning through their share of the allotment in violation of the law, and in that respect we were successful,” Anderson said. “Now the real work begins to collaborate with elected district leaders and win teachers the money they should have received over a year ago.”

Miles, speaking to the district advisory committee on Tuesday, celebrated the dismissal. “This is how we do it here, and I’ve made no bones about it,” he said. “I’m proud of the fact that we have a high performance culture.”