Federal Government Seizes Newark Housing Authority, Removes Board

The federal government seized control of the Newark Housing Authority on Thursday, removing its board of directors and installing HUD officials to run New Jersey’s largest public housing system.

The move caps a years-long descent into “troubled” status and follows a 2024 HUD report that cited lax financial oversight, high vacancy rates, and poor unit conditions across the authority’s 44 developments and 6,000 apartments, NBC New York reported.

In a letter posted to the authority’s website Thursday, HUD Assistant Secretary Benjamin Hobbs declared a “substantial default,” writing that the agency “has not taken good faith efforts to substantially improve” despite a 2024 agreement setting specific benchmarks.

“Ah, basically no. Because you have to understand Trump is out for himself and his cronies.”

Ahmed Ishma-el, tenant association president at Pennington Court, told NBC New York when asked if the administration could fix the problems. He described apartments “falling apart” and “garbage everywhere,” noting nine vacant units at his development alone and a shortage of maintenance staff.

The privatization dispute that precipitated the takeover

Tension had been building for months between the board — most members appointed by Mayor Ras Baraka and confirmed by the City Council — and Executive Director Leonard Spicer, a former HUD official hired in 2023 to steer the authority out of trouble. The board declined to extend Spicer’s contract last month. Baraka said the split centered on the authority’s push to privatize operations, a nationwide process that began in 2012.

Federal Government Seizes Newark Housing Authority, Removes Board
Photo: patch.com

“They brought on a new director, picked from the ranks of HUD itself, who presumably knew the issues and how to address them,” Baraka said. “In fact, they tied his contract to his ability to get them out of their troubled status.”

But the board and Spicer clashed over process and timeline, and HUD leadership warned Baraka that continued efforts to remove Spicer would trigger federal intervention. The authority was “only about five points away from getting out of troubled status,” Baraka said he relayed to board members.

Competing narratives on motive and accountability

HUD Secretary Scott Turner framed the takeover as accountability. “This decisive action demonstrates our commitment to holding public housing authorities accountable when they fall short of properly stewarding federal housing resources,” he said in a statement. The department says it aims to return the authority to local control once operations are stabilized.

Baraka sees a different motive: a power play to privatize the housing stock. “Termination of the board and silencing tenants’ voices is not the answer either,” the mayor wrote in a statement.

“Nor is force-feeding the city an ideology that guts the low-income housing business by defunding it and compelling families to be dominated and victimized by market forces.” He noted the authority owes the city roughly $17 million, remains one of Newark’s largest evictors, and holds the most vacant and abandoned property of any landowner in the city.

Newark hud kfqw facebookjumbo
Photo: dnyuz.com

Muhammed, who pinned the blame for the NHA’s woes on the mayor, welcomed federal management regardless of party. “I don’t care if it’s Trump. I don’t care if it’s Abraham Lincoln. Come and do the right thing for the Housing Authority. It benefits the tenants,” Muhammed told NBC New York. He argued the mayor’s control over commissioners and the executive director created an unaccountable loop.

Felicia Alston-Singleton, a longtime resident and advocate with the Greater Newark HUD Tenants Coalition, saw modest improvements in recent years but said meddling from local officials stalled progress. She called for federal oversight that centers residents. “This HUD takeover cannot be just another process in which the residents are being left out of the conversation,” she said. “Affected families should be included in every stage.”

Baraka, a Newark native and former Central High School principal, has been the city’s mayor since July 1, 2014, winning reelection in 2018, 2022 and 2026. Before leading the city, he served on the Municipal Council from 2002 to 2006 and again from 2010 to 2014, including a stint as deputy mayor. He sought the Democratic nomination for governor in 2025 but lost the primary to Mikie Sherrill.

What happens to the 200 city-refurbished units

Both Baraka and Muhammed flagged an immediate concern: roughly 200 authority units that the city refurbished and furnished for formerly homeless residents. Baraka said those tenants must not be displaced.

The authority’s website noted Thursday that board responsibilities had been transferred to HUD’s Deputy Assistant Secretary Shylon Ferry and Associate Deputy Assistant Secretary Daniel Sherrod, and that day-to-day operations would continue under federal oversight. A board meeting scheduled for Friday was canceled.