Former State Rep Paul Cillo: Property Tax, Not Schools, Drives Crisis

Property tax bills in Vermont have jumped an average of 33 percent in just three years, a figure Gov. Phil Scott cited in his 2025 inaugural address to declare an affordability crisis.

In his 2025 inaugural address Gov. Phil Scott decried rising education property taxes.

Paul Cillo, a former state representative from Hardwick who helped write Act 60 in 1997, argues the governor has misdiagnosed the problem. The schools are not failing; the funding mechanism is. “What’s unaffordable is not public education. What’s unaffordable for many Vermonters is the property tax itself,” Cillo wrote in a column distributed across the Reformer, the Bennington Banner, and the Caledonian-Record. Paul A.

The regressive mechanics

Cillo outlines four structural failures. First, the tax is regressive: low- and middle-income homeowners pay a higher share of their income than wealthier neighbors. Second, a home’s value does not write the check — the homeowner’s income does.

Yet income-sensitivity protections that once covered nearly 70 percent of homeowners have eroded; only 42 percent now qualify to pay school taxes based on income rather than property value. A home’s value doesn’t pay the property tax bill. The homeowner’s income does.

Former State Rep Paul Cillo: Property Tax, Not Schools, Drives Crisis
Photo: reformer.com

Third, the tax subjects owners to real estate market swings they cannot control. A reassessment can spike a bill even if the local school budget is flat. Fourth, the system is unstable: nearly every year the Legislature patches a “crisis” with a one-time infusion of $100 million or more from state coffers. The property tax is an unstable foundation for public education.

A decades-long agenda

Scott has pursued this line since his first budget address in 2017. Vermont Public reported then that his proposed state takeover of funding decisions and diversion of K-12 money to childcare and higher education would constitute “an unprecedented legislative intervention in local education spending.” A year later, VTDigger reported, he sought to cut 200 school staff positions annually for five years.

Cillo frames the governor’s current “transformation” rhetoric as the same playbook: consolidate districts, centralize control, and cut spending. “Spending less is not the first step to making them better for kids,” he wrote.

Former State Rep Paul Cillo: Property Tax, Not Schools, Drives Crisis
Photo: caledonianrecord.com

The 18th-century anchor

Vermont relies on the property tax because it was the only viable option in the 18th century, Cillo notes. The state has broader tax bases now — income, sales, corporate — but lacks the political will to shift. Until it does, the cycle of spikes, patches, and consolidation talk will continue. We have other options now. We need the political will to implement them.

Paul Cillo founded the Public Assets Institute in 2003 and led it for 19 years, steering research that helped make Vermont’s school funding system the most equitable in the nation and secured passage of a universal pre-K program and an expanded Earned Income Tax Credit.

Before that, he spent 10 years in the Vermont House representing Hardwick, Walden, and Stannard, including four years as Majority Leader and four on the tax-writing Ways & Means Committee, where he designed and steered Act 60 of 1997, the groundbreaking law that equalized education opportunity statewide.

“It’s time to stop the disruptive nonsense about so-called education transformation and shift to property tax transformation,” Cillo wrote. “Once we’ve stabilized funding, the state can focus on how to make schools work better for our kids.” Once we’ve stabilized funding, the state can focus on how to make schools work better for our kids.