More than 30 Pennsylvania farmers, agribusinesses and organizations endorsed a letter to U.S. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin asking for reform of worker visa programs and the aggressive tactics Immigrations and Customs Enforcement agents use to target immigrant workers, Pennsylvania Capital-Star reported.
The letter, authored by PennAg Industries Association President Christian Herr, warns that employees with legal status have been detained in recent enforcement actions and that aggressive targeting has caused workers with valid visas to miss work out of fear.
“Due to an aging and declining population, and a lack of interest on behalf of many nativeborn Americans, it is essential that our industry be able to utilize an immigrant workforce,” Herr wrote.
Gov. Josh Shapiro and state Agriculture Secretary Russell Redding met with a group of those business leaders Thursday in Lancaster County to hear the impact firsthand. “It was important for me to hear directly how these immigration challenges — immigration enforcement challenges — were affecting you,” Shapiro said. He acknowledged that most reforms require federal action but pledged to use his “loud voice” to press Pennsylvania’s congressional delegation.

ICE Detains Three Workers at Farm
Sarah Zost, president of the State Horticultural Association of Pennsylvania and an Adams County fruit grower, described how ICE agents detained three workers from her farm during morning commute traffic stops. The three made up a quarter of her winter crew. “Two of them had worked for us for over a decade, and one has a wife and kids who go to my local school district,” she said.
Zost said the agents held a warrant for a neighbor of one worker, not for any of her employees. “They were looking for a neighbor of one of them and just happened to see [workers] carpooling to work in the morning of the target demographic and pulled them over,” she told Pennsylvania Capital-Star.
All three agreed to self-deport, which typically triggers a three-year or longer bar on reentry. “Being here legally does not get you a get-out-of-jail-free card from harassment for ICE,” Zost said. “There’s a culture of fear and concern because you get targeted because of what you look like.”
The chilling effect spreads instantly. “There are worker chats and farmer chats of any sightings of ICE in the area, and everyone will stay home to avoid those kinds of interactions,” she said. “It causes lost time on all farms because workers, regardless of visa status, stay home.”
Poultry’s visa gap and an executive order that upended six-year pipelines
Astin Melhorn, president of Paragon Poultry Management Group, said poultry workers do not qualify for the seasonal H-2A visa used by crop farms.
Since 2015 his company has sponsored dozens of employees through the EB-3 permanent residency program, a multi-year process that had been predictable until this year. Eight employees nearing the end of that six-year pipeline learned that President Donald Trump had signed an executive order halting all visas from Guatemala.
“That’s a very frustrating thing when you’re an employer trying to do things correctly,” Melhorn said. His operation also felt the enforcement wave: 17 workers were detained earlier this year, including some with work permits. “[They] were shipped as far as Oklahoma,” he said.
“When they were released, they had to find their own way back to Pennsylvania … Some self-deported, some have cases and so they’re working through those, and some were released.”
“That very much rocked our world and rocked our industry.”
Republican Bill Expands H-2A Eligibility
Herr and others at the roundtable pushed for passage of the Securing Agriculture’s Workforce Act, sponsored by Pennsylvania Republican Rep. Glenn Thompson, the outgoing chair of the House Agriculture Committee.
The bill would let H-2A visa holders stay year-round, expand eligibility to agriculture-related businesses like poultry, and create a pathway for experienced unauthorized farmworkers to apply for H-2A status. The measure has 61 co-sponsors, including 10 Democrats; Rep. Chrissy Houlahan is the only Pennsylvania Democrat currently signed on.
Herr said he has heard from many in agriculture who consider themselves conservative — some who voted for Trump — but are uncomfortable with how the mass deportation program has played out. “We look at the talking heads throughout the country who, from time to time, state that Americans voted for deporting 20 million people. I think that’s a misread,” he said.
“Because I can tell you that there are many, many folks in this community, from this sector, from agriculture and agribusiness, who don’t feel that way. I would say a large majority of them don’t.”
Next year Democrats will hold majorities in both the U.S. House and Senate after an election widely seen as a rebuke to Trump. “This idea with congressmen who are afraid of the White House and pander to — I think that changed,” Herr said.
“I’ve had some conversations with local congressmen about this and I do think there’s a reassessment of this issue and where the constituents are. When you have a room full of folks from construction, and agriculture and healthcare, it’s a meaningful point to say, ‘Look this really needs to be maturely addressed.’”
Christian Herr has led the PennAg Industries Association, representing more than 400 farmers and food companies across central Pennsylvania counties, since 2003.
A former Republican legislative aide, he said the avian influenza crisis that forced farms to destroy millions of chickens also brought him onto worksites alongside immigrant crews who were earning about $80,000 a year; when immigration agents later removed 17 of those workers, the experience shaped his advocacy for a functional visa system.
For Herr, the issue turned personal after immigrant workers helped his businesses survive Pennsylvania’s avian influenza outbreak. “They’re looking over their shoulders. They’re uncomfortable. They’re always wondering when their time is gonna be up here,” he said.
“There’s people who have been here for a quarter century, who have raised their families here. It’s sort of Congress and whoever is in the White House to say, ‘Alright, let’s do a reset here.’”