Fossil-Fuel Industry Accused of Violating Colorado Law Over Not Disclosing Drilling Chemicals

“This is a public health crisis and it should be treated as such,” Shannon Smith told the Guardian.

Fossil-fuel companies operating in Colorado are violating state law by failing to disclose which chemicals they inject into the earth during the drilling phase of oil and gas production, a new nonprofit analysis alleges. State records show these operators have used illegal or dangerous compounds while fracking across the state.

A first-in-the-nation 2022 Colorado law requires fossil-fuel operators and their suppliers to make public all chemicals used in downhole oil and gas production. Yet regulators have exempted compounds used specifically during the drilling phase, arguing that drilling falls outside the legal definition of production.

The FracTracker Alliance disputes this interpretation. The nonprofit organization argues that the exemption contradicts the widely accepted definition of production found in industry and regulatory literature.

State legislators who authored the law, public health advocates, and industry groups all define production to include drilling. The statute explicitly mandates the disclosure of all chemicals used underground in oil and gas wells.

Colorado renewable energy society

Meanwhile, fossil-fuel companies reported using at least five chemicals prohibited by Colorado law, according to the FracTracker analysis. Operators also reported using at least three highly toxic chemicals that raise serious safety questions.

About 43,000 people live within a mile of the state’s active wells, with many residing just a few hundred feet away. Regulators are flying blind regarding the cumulative impact of these unlisted compounds.

Fracking operators and their suppliers are required to disclose all downhole chemical ingredients to the Colorado Energy and Carbon Management Commission within 150 days. The agency then publishes the disclosures on its official website.

ECMC literature implies the agency considers drilling as part of oil and gas production. In an official statement, an ECMC spokesperson said the agency is aware of differing views regarding the scope and implementation of chemical disclosure requirements.

“We are applying the law and Commission rules under the current statutory and regulatory framework while continuing to work with stakeholders to clarify these issues and support consistent, appropriate implementation, said an ECMC spokesperson.”

A Chevron spokesperson said that the company remains committed to safe and responsible operations in Colorado.

“We take chemical-disclosure requirements seriously and remain focused on meeting our obligations and maintaining transparent, responsible operating practices, a Chevron spokesperson added.”

To extract minerals, operators pump massive volumes of pressurized liquid into bedrock to fracture the earth. While these fluids consist mostly of water and sand, they also contain industrial chemicals such as biocides, surfactants, and lubricants.

Dusty Horwitt, a senior research and policy consultant with FracTracker who co-authored the report, said that the ECMC told the organization it does not consider drilling to be part of fracking and production.

That was news to us, and it is not consistent with The American Petroleum Institute definition of what oil and gas production is, Horwitt told the Guardian. Dusty Horwitt

Colorado state representative Meg Froelich, who co-wrote the 2022 legislation, confirmed she intended for drilling chemicals to be disclosed under the statute titled concerning enhanced oversight of the chemicals used in oil and gas production.

“The law covers everything that goes downhole because everything that goes downhole has the potential to affect neighbors, Froelich told the Guardian.”

She accused the ECMC of word-parsing and expressed frustration with their stalling. State records indicate that wells covered by the law operated without drilling chemical disclosure for a collective total of 843,369 days from the rules’ implementation to May 16.