Goehring Says Grant ‘Did What They Said

Plans for a Burnsville, Minnesota medical device manufacturer to open a facility in Fargo fell through, yet the company is permitted to keep a $1.1 million state grant, North Dakota Agriculture Commissioner Doug Goehring told The Forum.

The financial award forms part of a broader state audit released this week examining the North Dakota Bioscience Innovation grants. The review indicates that nearly half of the $8.4 million distributed through the program went to recipients who failed to establish a physical presence within North Dakota boundaries, though the audit document itself does not explicitly name the ineligible entities.

Legislators initially established the Bioscience Innovation Grant in 2019 to foster local bioscience development and generate jobs. State law required eligible recipients to maintain at least two employees, document annual sales under $2.5 million, and register their business within the state.

Imricor Medical Systems, founded in 2006, manufactures products for cardiac ablations, which treat irregular heart rhythms. The North Dakota Department of Agriculture awarded the firm $1,158,000 in 2023, representing the largest grant from a pool of 39 grants totaling $10.9 million in state funding.

The capital was explicitly designated for “the final steps in commercialization of a new technology for cardiac ablation procedures in the United States.” While the company planned to repurpose a 15,000-square-foot office in the Fargo metro area to house 20 “high-paying technical positions” with assistance from the Greater Fargo-Moorhead Economic Development Corp., those physical expansion plans ultimately collapsed.

Goehring Says Grant 'Did What They Said

“They weren’t able to move, but they continued to do the work, and they did develop the products they said they would,” Goehring told The Forum.

Conflicting Interpretations of Statutory Requirements

The core dispute centers on whether a physical office was legally mandatory to retain the funding. Goehring maintains that the authorizing legislation did not mandate a physical operating location inside North Dakota, noting that Imricor satisfied all statutory prerequisites before receiving the reimbursement.

“They met the requirement to be eligible, and they followed through and created and did what they said they would do, so why wouldn’t they be reimbursed?” Goehring said, adding that the state could face a lawsuit if it didn’t give Imricor the grants.

State Auditor Josh Gallion strongly contested that interpretation. The audit also found that the Ag Department omitted site visits and performance reviews for recipients, while failing to require documentary proof of compliance from applicants.

Goehring Says Grant 'Did What They Said

“To me, when you talk about operating, and when you look at the purpose of this grant, it seems like this is to help foster and create a bioscience industry in North Dakota, which would, to me, imply that these businesses should be here creating jobs in North Dakota for North Dakotans,” Gallion said.

Goehring pushed back against the audit findings, characterizing the public release as misleading. He emphasized that his agency operated without adequate authority to hold people accountable or conduct necessary reviews, acknowledging that his department did not complete site visits and performance reviews for the grant recipients.

“It feels like it’s just clickbait for the auditor to put out a press release like this when the public’s already up in arms,” Goehring told The Forum, adding that the statute governing the initiative needs to be completely gutted and redone.

Records indicate that Imricor pursued multiple avenues of state backing alongside the agriculture grant. The North Dakota Commerce Department awarded the firm a $1 million loan through the North Dakota Development Fund in 2023, though Commerce Department Kim Schmidt confirmed the company declined the terms by email in September 2023, leaving those funds undisbursed.

Separately, the company secured a $1.5 million loan via the Innovation Technology Loan Fund, or LIFT, in 2023, which the company has paid back in full, according to its 2025 annual report. However, filing paperwork submitted to the Secretary of State’s Office on November 11, 2025, shows that Imricor formally withdrew its registration as a North Dakota business, rendering its local corporate status inactive.

Gallion’s office recommended that the Ag Department perform a comprehensive review to identify ineligible recipients and evaluate the feasibility of clawing back funds, noting that nine grant recipients lacked state addresses and six failed to document earnings under the $2.5 million threshold. While the Ag Department concurred with the recommendation for a review, Goehring stated his office found all initial recipients eligible and has no current plans to seek reimbursements.

“If you’re going to have me run the program, give me the authority to hold people accountable,” Goehring told The Forum.