Hague District Court Issues Preliminary Injunction Banning BYD Ti7 Sales in EU Over Defender Design

“The characteristic and distinctive elements of the design are reflected in the BYD Ti7,” the District Court of The Hague ruled on Friday, finding the Chinese automaker’s seven-seat SUV infringes Jaguar Land Rover’s registered EU design for the Land Rover Defender 110.

The preliminary injunction bars BYD and ten European subsidiaries from importing, producing, offering, selling, storing or delivering the Ti7 anywhere in the European Union, effective one week after formal service of the judgment, The Guardian reported.

Differences highlighted by BYD were “not striking enough to change the overall impression,” the court said. Penalties for breach run to €100,000 per day or €25,000 per vehicle, capped at €10 million, and an appeal does not suspend enforcement, CarSauce reported.

The injunction extends to BYD Auto Hungary, where the company had been expected to start building the Ti7 at its new Szeged plant before year-end, though the court noted BYD had not yet decided to produce the model there, The Guardian reported.

BYD’s British subsidiary, BYD (U.K.) Co., Limited, falls outside the order because the Dutch court found it lacks jurisdiction over the UK entity and saw no evidence the Dutch companies controlled UK sales, CarNewsChina.com reported. UK pre-orders opened in July at £47,995 — roughly £24,000 below the Defender’s starting price — with customer deliveries still slated for January 2027, The The Telegraph reported.

Photo: CnEVPost

“Legal proceedings are ongoing and we won’t be commenting further at this time,” JLR said in a statement.

BYD “strongly disagrees” with the ruling and will appeal, maintaining the Ti7 — sold in China as the Fang Cheng Bao Tai 7 — is the product of its own independent design work and infringes none of JLR’s rights, The Guardian reported. The Ti7 has accumulated more than 300,000 global sales since its Chinese launch last September, CnEVPost reported.

Differences highlighted by BYD were insufficient to detract from the otherwise very similar looks, The The Telegraph reported.

The court also determined that five other registered JLR designs were not assessed in the preliminary judgment, which concerns the registered EU design for the Defender Type L663 under case C/09/712003 / KG ZA 26-956, a court notice showed.

The judge found insufficient evidence that BYD’s Dutch entities had offered or promoted the Ti7 in Britain, CnEVPost reported.

Photo: The The Telegraph

The dispute is unusual in Europe, where major automakers rarely litigate design rights; JLR’s last comparable win came in 2019 after a three-year battle against Jiangling Motors Corporation over a copycat vehicle, The Guardian reported.

BYD’s European expansion centers on its first EU passenger-vehicle factory, BYD Auto Hungary, where the company had planned to start building the Ti7 in Szeged before year-end, The Guardian reported. The preliminary injunction bars that Hungarian unit from producing the model anywhere in the European Union, creating immediate uncertainty for a plant intended to anchor BYD’s regional manufacturing footprint.

A separate JLR case alleging copyright infringement and “slavish imitation” is scheduled for a Rotterdam District Court hearing on November 25, and JLR must commence full proceedings on the merits within six months or the injunction can lapse, CarNewsChina.com reported.

The dispute is unusual in Europe, where major automakers rarely litigate design rights; JLR’s last comparable win came in 2019 after a three-year battle against Jiangling Motors Corporation over a copycat vehicle, The Guardian reported.