- Verdict followed a weeklong trial over Lundry’s 2024 firing after he criticized the city’s chief hiring process.
- Jury rejected Lundry’s due-process and state whistleblower claims.
The eight-member jury awarded Lundry $850,000 in economic damages to be paid jointly by the city, City Manager Tyler Deems, Deputy City Manager Jeff Aprati and former Mayor Stan Pulliam, oregonlive.com reported.
Jurors also imposed individual punitive damages: $50,000 against Pulliam, $25,000 against Deems and $10,000 against Aprati.
The jury found for Lundry on his First Amendment retaliation claim but ruled against him on due-process and name-clearing-hearing claims, as well as on a state whistleblower-retaliation claim, according to the verdict form filed Nov. 20, 2026, in Lundry v. City of Sandy, No. 3:24-cv-01433.
Speech that triggered the case
Lundry, a 20-year law-enforcement veteran who joined the Sandy Police Department in 2015 and became interim chief in August 2023, applied for the permanent post and was one of three finalists. On Jan. 16, 2024, he was told the city had selected Gary Jensen, a Utah police chief from Logan City, bloomministries.org reported.

After learning he had been passed over, Lundry encouraged community members to file public records requests about the hiring process and posted on Facebook that he would never accept the chief’s job “with the current mayor, council, and appointed leadership,” according to his complaint.
The city initially withheld comment cards from a candidate forum; it released them only after the Clackamas County District Attorney’s Office ordered it to do so, kptv.com reported.
Deems places Lundry on leave over shredding allegation
On Feb. 23, 2024, Deems placed Lundry on paid administrative leave and referred an anonymous allegation — submitted on one of the comment cards — that Lundry had shredded public records for a criminal investigation.
Oregon State Police investigated; by April 15 the district attorney’s office concluded there was no evidence Lundry had unlawfully destroyed records, according to the parties’ pretrial order cited by kptv.com. An independent administrative investigation also found no basis for four allegations raised against Lundry, including bullying and harassment.

Deems notified Lundry of the city’s intent to terminate him on May 22, and Lundry was fired June 18, 2024. He later moved to Tennessee, where he works as a probation officer after being unable to find law-enforcement work in Oregon, his lawyers said.
Pulliam denies role but acknowledges meeting with finalist Jensen
At trial, Pulliam repeatedly testified he had no role in the chief selection process, saying, “Quite frankly, I’m wondering why I’m here. All these decisions were Mr. Deems. That’s how our city government works … I wasn’t part of the process,” oregonlive.com reported.
However, under cross-examination he acknowledged meeting with finalist Jensen after a January 2024 community forum and admitting he had asked to meet any candidate other than Lundry whom Deems might select. “I get to have an opinion,” Pulliam said when pressed.
Council President Laurie Smallwood testified that during a Feb. 20, 2024, executive session, Pulliam and another council member “wanted to fire Sean and figure out a way to get rid of him” after Jensen’s selection was announced, citing concerns that Lundry was “going to social media” and “wasn’t toeing the line.” Three days later, Deems placed Lundry on leave.
Text messages shown to jurors revealed Deems writing to his deputy in mid-February that he was “so (expletive) done” with the selection process and expressing dismay about social media reaction: “The people who haven’t gotten over their pride are the ones who continue to stir this (expletive) up every freakin’ month.” Deems testified he “regrettably” used foul language.
City’s defense
City attorney Kim E. Hoyt argued at trial that Lundry worked to undermine the department after being passed over and that his social media criticism while still interim chief was not constitutionally protected speech. The city also alleged Lundry recorded a conversation with Deems without his knowledge and said it would have fired him for that reason alone, kptv.com reported.
What comes next
Motions remain pending, so the verdict is not the final word in the case, bloomministries.org reported.