Hawaii County Committee Advances Bill to Ban Large-Scale Data Centers

“This definition is a product of the island doing our homework,” Hilo resident Tina Holt told the Hawaii County Council’s Policy Committee on Planning, Land Use and Economic Development on Tuesday.

The committee voted unanimously to advance Bill 170, which would prohibit large-scale data centers anywhere in the county, with a tightened definition that quantifies electricity and water thresholds.

Introduced in July by Councilmember Heather Kimball, the bill aims to close a zoning loophole that currently permits “data processing facilities” in industrial-commercial mixed-use districts — language Kimball said was “originally intended for standard office computer rooms rather than sprawling warehouse facilities housing tens of thousands of power-hungry servers.”

The amended version specifies that a data center is a “building or group of buildings” with a “maximum rated power capacity or total peak power load from all sources at full build out of at least five megawatts; and contains computing equipment with an aggregate electrical demand of at least one megawatt, excluding cooling and building systems, any portion of which is housed in racks or enclosures designed to deliver at least twenty kilowatts each, or is cooled by direct-to-chip liquid cooling or immersion cooling.”

Both the Windward and Leeward Planning Commissions reviewed the measure in October. The Windward panel forwarded an unfavorable recommendation, citing confusion over the definition, while the Leeward panel endorsed a favorable recommendation and went further, recommending a moratorium on data centers and asking the Council to refine the definition.

“Both planning commissions really had concerns about the definition,” Kimball said Tuesday. “What you see before you in this communication is an amalgamation of all those different recommendations, addressing some of the concerns brought up here by the telecom folks and the utilities.”

Photo: newzly.net

Representatives of Hawaiian Telcom and Spectrum testified in support of the amendment, seeking assurance that their existing and planned telecommunications infrastructure would not be captured. “I just want to be clear that Hawaiian Telcom is not taking a position on whether or not the council should prohibit large-scale data centers,” said Jeannine Souki of Hawaiian Telcom’s Government and Regulatory Affairs Office.

“Our request is limited to ensuring that the definition doesn’t unintentionally apply to our existing and planned telecommunications facilities and network infrastructure that keep voice, video and internet services running.” The bill includes explicit exceptions for government operations, civil defense, hospital medical record keeping, higher education institutions, telecommunications and public utilities, protecting facilities such as Hawaiian Telcom’s Kawaihae site and the University of Hawaii at Hilo data center.

“In the interim since we first saw this and the planning commission meetings have happened, there’s really been a national movement towards moratoriums, prohibitions,” Kimball said, adding “it’s very clear folks are in agreement that data centers don’t belong in our county.” The committee advanced the bill with nine aye votes; it now moves to the full Hawaii County Council for formal consideration and subsequent readings.

Hawai'i County Council – November 18, 2026 (53rd Session) — Hawaii County Council

Council member warns against loophole exploitation

“I just want to point out that the problem is the nefarious loophole finders and their intentions, and our job is to do the best we can,” he said.

Committee unanimously approves amended bill

The committee ultimately voted unanimously in support of the amended bill.

Heather Kimball, Councilmember for District 1 since 2020 and Council Chair from 2022 to 2024, has championed sustainability and land-use measures throughout her tenure. She created the self-funded Office of Sustainability, Climate, Equity, and Resilience, established a public EV charging infrastructure requirement, and secured the purchase of 80 acres at Kawainui through the Public Open Space Fund.

Kimball also reformed agricultural tax programs to curb speculative investment and land banking of productive farmlands, created a senior farmer tax abatement program, and passed short-term vacation rental regulation to address illegal vacation rentals. As Vice-Chair of the Energy, Environment & Land Use Committee and a member of the EPA Local Government Advisory Committee, she has focused on resource protection and resilient planning.

Resource impacts drive prohibition effort

The bill said that “the added definition does not encourage or allow the permitting of data centers but aims to make clear that they are not a permitted use in the County.”