Cornyn Blocks Trump Judicial Nominee Amid Cruz Shouting Match

The dispute erupted into a shouting match on the Senate floor Tuesday between Cornyn and fellow Texas Republican Ted Cruz, who supports Gaiser’s nomination. Cruz confirmed that Cornyn was “shouting at me and cursing at me,” while Trump told Fox News’ “Saturday in America” that Cornyn’s opposition stems from his primary defeat to Ken Paxton. “He feels badly about it,” Trump said. “He's a nice guy, John Cornyn, but he's doing a tremendous disservice because Gaiser is fantastic.”

Blue Slip Gives Cornyn Veto Over District Court Pick

The Senate’s “blue slip” tradition gives home-state senators veto power over district court nominees. Judiciary Committee Chair Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) still honors the practice, meaning Cornyn’s refusal to return the slip for Gaiser effectively kills the nomination. The Wall Street Journal noted that Republicans have only seven weeks — including Thanksgiving and Christmas — to confirm judges before Chuck Schumer assumes majority control in January.

Cruz Endorses Gaiser Nomination for Dallas Judgeship

Cruz, who chairs the Senate Commerce Committee, interviewed Gaiser and signed off enthusiastically. “Elliot's wife is in Dallas. His wife's family is in Dallas. He wanted to be there in Dallas,” Cruz told CBS News. “His background check is complete. The paperwork is complete. So it was possible to nominate him and get him confirmed by the end of the year. I thought it was a great idea.”

Shouting Match Erupts on Senate Floor

The clash became public Tuesday when Cruz approached Cornyn about the nomination. Newsweek reported that Cruz said Cornyn was “shouting at me and cursing at me on the Senate floor, and that's what the reporters in the gallery reported on.” Cruz linked the outburst to Cornyn’s primary loss: “Losing an election is hard, and people get upset about it. I understand that. I understand that frustration.”

Cornyn fired back on X, calling Cruz “fragile.” “Everyone knows that I am a notorious cusser and screamer and that Ted is a fragile thing,” Cornyn wrote. The exchange escalated Saturday when Trump weighed in, saying Cornyn would have lost the general election “by a lot” had he not been defeated in the primary.

Justice Department and Allies Defend Gaiser

The Justice Department issued a statement calling Cornyn’s refusal “political obstruction” and describing Gaiser as a “highly qualified nominee.” Hillsdale College President Larry Arnn told the college newspaper that Gaiser is capable of leading that movement toward originalist jurisprudence, while Professor Nathan Schlueter said he has shown “exemplary intelligence, discipline, and character” since his student days.

The Washington Examiner reported that a source familiar with the confirmation process called Cornyn’s alternative candidate Steve Fahey a “red herring,” citing the unrealistic logistics and time required to vet a replacement before the Senate changes hands.

Cornyn blocks Trump judicial nominee for Texas federal bench — CBS19

Cornyn Defends Process Objections on Social Media

Cornyn wrote on X Saturday questioning why Trump waited until after the midterms to nominate someone for a seat that “has been vacant since 2025,” according to the New York Post via Reuters. “Time is of the essence,” Cornyn added in a follow-up post noted by Newsweek.

Cornyn told the Associated Press he has “no intention of returning the blue slip” for Gaiser, and said the White House had requested information about his preferred candidate, Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey.

Trump says Sen Cornyn blocking Dallas judicial pick is a 'tremendous disservice'
Photo: Fox News

Cornyn told reporters the Senate is not supposed to be a rubber stamp, and that he had been invited multiple times by Cruz to meet with Gaiser but declined because the White House made it “impossible” for him to support the nominee without Texas vetting.

Vacancy Would Hand Seat to Democrats, Cruz Warns

Cruz warned that failure to confirm Gaiser would hand the seat to Democrats indefinitely. “If the Senate Judiciary Committee does not move Gaiser forward, the people of Texas will pay the price because it will effectively give the judicial seat to the Democrats, who will keep it vacant in perpetuity,” Cruz told the Washington Examiner.

Democratic Senator-elect James Talarico will replace Cornyn on January 3 and would then control the blue slip for the vacancy.

The White House faces a midnight deadline for Cornyn to release his blue slip before a scheduled hearing. A White House official said the administration expects all of Trump’s judicial nominees to be confirmed by year’s end.

Trump CALLS OUT Cornyn for Blocking nominee: 'Feelings were hurt' — Fox News