Hochul Calls Outages ‘Deeply Unsettling’ but Says NY ‘Fully Confident’ in Cyber Readiness

“Deeply unsettling” but “fully confident” — that is the line Gov. Kathy Hochul drew Tuesday as she faced reporters at Queens Borough Hall, hours after a Federal Aviation Administration communication failure grounded flights nationwide and a ransomware attack paralyzed all 66 branches of the Queens Public Library, CBS News reported.

The back-to-back incidents — Friday's four-hour national ground stop and the library breach discovered over the weekend — have forced state and city leaders to confront a question that has been building for weeks: whether the cascade of airline, banking and cloud-service outages points to a fragile digital backbone or a coordinated threat.

Hochul said her intelligence and cybersecurity teams have been briefing her daily since the first Microsoft Outlook disruptions more than a week ago, leaning on federal contacts to determine what is driving the instability.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani, standing separately in Astoria, echoed the governor’s assurance but broke sharply on the federal response. “Frankly, the response that we heard from federal officials was far from what many wanted to hear, and it did not leave many New Yorkers with any greater sense of confidence about our national capabilities in case of this occurring again,” Mamdani said, criticizing the secrecy surrounding the FAA outage’s cause.

He told reporters the city’s Office of Technological Innovation is now at the forefront of local preparation, a posture he said was reinforced by the 25th anniversary commemorations of the Sept. 11 attacks, which included instructions to every agency to ready themselves for large-scale disruption, including cyberattack, amNewYork reported.

Hochul
Photo: amny.com

Hochul acknowledged she “was not confident” in the state’s crisis readiness when she first took office. Since then, she said, she has assembled what she calls the best state-level cybersecurity response team in the country, conducted exercises for “every possible scenario” — including end-of-day catastrophes — and hardened critical infrastructure across transportation, nuclear plants, energy, water and sewer systems.

The state has also distributed grants to localities that lacked the resources to fortify their own networks, according to New York City News.

“We’ve done this in the city as well, and other localities. I’ve also hardened our infrastructure, and what that means is when you look at the most vulnerable assets, our transportation systems, our nuclear plants, our energy systems, our water systems, our sewer systems.”

Gov. Kathy Hochul

The governor did not detail the specific exercises, the grant amounts or the technical measures taken, leaving a gap that security experts say makes independent verification impossible.

A Johns Hopkins University study released this month warned of a looming national shortage of large power transformers and converters — equipment with lead times measured in years — that could cripple grid recovery after a major cyber or physical attack. Hochul said she intends to review the specific materials cited in the study because her administration has ambitious plans to build out the state’s energy grid.

From below of long thin blue cables connected to row of small white connectors on system block in data center
Photo: newyorkcitysnews.com

On the ground, the anxiety is personal. One Queens resident told CBS News they are stockpiling water and food because “you don’t know what could happen.” Another, a parent, described the nightmare of children trapped in a darkened subway tunnel with no way to communicate.

A third shrugged off the preparation: “I’m not buying any special provisions. I’m just living my life day to day. It’s the only way to do it.”

The Queens library system, which serves millions of patrons, remained partially offline Tuesday as forensic investigators worked to determine the ransomware variant and whether patron data was exfiltrated. Officials have not disclosed a ransom demand or a timeline for full restoration.

The FAA, meanwhile, has yet to release a root-cause analysis for the Friday ground stop, attributing it only to a “communication outage” in its Notice to Air Missions system — the same system that failed in January 2023, grounding flights for hours.

That opacity fuels the tension between the governor’s confidence and the mayor’s frustration. Hochul’s team says the state is monitoring around the clock. Mamdani says the city is prepared but insists the federal government must be more transparent about what broke and why. Between those two positions sit millions of New Yorkers wondering whether the next outage will be an inconvenience or a catastrophe.

“What we were hearing from some of the secretaries that day was in no way confidence-building,” Mamdani said of the federal briefing after Friday’s ground stop.