Commonwealth Court Judge Lori Dumas announced Monday she will seek the Democratic nomination for the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in 2027, entering a race that could reshape a court with a 4-2-1 partisan split, PoliticsPA reported.
The announcement came the same day court spokesperson Stacey Witalic confirmed Chief Justice Debra Todd does not plan to seek retention in 2027, and Justice Christine Donohue faces mandatory retirement at age 75 next December, according to News From The States and Penn Capital-Star. Those two departures would open seats on a seven-member court that has decided redistricting, election law, and the legality of skill-games machines in recent terms.
“I’m running to be a justice on Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court because I believe Pennsylvanians deserve a justice who brings experience, independence, compassion, and an unwavering commitment to the rule of law to the bench,” Dumas said in her campaign announcement. “As a judge with 24 years on the bench and as a mother of three, my commitment to those Pennsylvania values is deeply personal.”
Pennsylvania’s justices run in partisan elections for 10-year terms, then face yes-or-no retention votes. The current lineup: Chief Justice Debra Todd, Justices Christine Donohue, Kevin Dougherty, David Wecht, Sallie Updyke Mundy, P. Kevin Brobson, and Daniel McCaffery, according to abc27. Four were elected as Democrats, two as Republicans, and Wecht switched to Independent in May over what he called “anti-Jewish” actions within the Democratic Party, multiple outlets reported.

Donohue, first elected in 2015 and retained in 2025, must step down in December 2027 when she turns 75. Todd, first elected in 2007, turns 70 next year and her term expires December 2027; Witalic said she is not planning to seek retention, News From The States and Penn Capital-Star reported. Mundy, a Republican, turns 65 next year and faces a retention vote in January 2028.
The 2025 retention elections for Dougherty, Wecht, and Donohue drew more than $14 million in campaign spending plus millions more from outside groups, Penn Capital-Star and News From The States noted. The 2027 cycle is expected to attract similar money.
Dumas, 58, was elected to Commonwealth Court in 2021 after nearly two decades on the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, where she presided over family, criminal, and civil divisions, abc27 and PoliticsPA reported. Appointed as one of the youngest judges in Philadelphia history, she helped establish the city’s first Juvenile Human Trafficking Court and chairs the Supreme Court’s Judicial Ethics Advisory Board, according to PoliticsPA.

“The law must work the same for everyone who walks into a Pennsylvania courtroom — no matter their ZIP code, their income, or their circumstances,” Dumas said.
“In the trial court, I protected children, families, and victims of violence. In the appellate court, I have been tasked with balancing the power of government with the voice of the people. I am running for the Supreme Court to bring that same fidelity to the law — and to every Pennsylvanian it serves.”
She earned her law degree from North Carolina Central University School of Law and her bachelor’s from Duke University, and has taught at Temple University, abc27 reported. Her Commonwealth Court term runs through December 2031.
The 2027 primary is scheduled for May 18, with the general election on November 2, abc27 reported. Republicans see the open seats as their best chance to flip the court since 2015; Democrats will argue the current majority has protected voting rights and reproductive access. Dumas is the first declared candidate for either party.