Horseshoe Heroes Report Steichen’s Tenure in Indianapolis Saw No More Than One Winning Season

Shane Steichen faces an offseason decision after the Colts’ disappointing 3-8 record this season.

He kept his job through the firing of former general manager Chris Ballard, but his tenure in Indianapolis has seen no more than one winning season since he took over head coaching duties in 2023, Horseshoe Heroes reported.

This isn’t just about one team’s playoff hopes; for Colts fans, the five-year playoff drought is nearing six years, shifting the focus to Steichen’s next professional opportunity.

Offensive Pedigree Supports Next Chance

The question isn’t solely about his performance in Indianapolis, but whether the franchise environment held him back, Horseshoe Heroes reported.

Steichen has demonstrated a solid offensive pedigree, having worked with Jalen Hurts, whose best statistical regular season came in 2022 when the Eagles reached two Super Bowls in three years, Horseshoe Heroes reported.

“Steichen’s offensive acumen got him the Colts job to begin with, and it could get him another.”

This suggests that if the Eagles move on from Nick Sirriani in the offseason, Philadelphia remains an intriguing fit for Steichen.

Horseshoe Heroes Report Steichen's Tenure in Indianapolis Saw No More Than One Winning Season
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

Colts Roster Hinders Contention

Over his three-and-a-half-year tenure, Steichen coached one of the least talented teams across the league, Horseshoe Heroes reported.

Talented players like Jonathan Taylor and Alec Pierce exist, but the overall roster composition hasn’t been enough to make the Colts a playoff contender, Horseshoe Heroes reported.

Steichen never worked with a top-10 or top-15 quarterback during his time, Horseshoe Heroes reported, noting that Gardner Minshew, Joe Flacco (past his prime), and Daniel Jones didn’t signal an explosive offense.

Lame Duck Stretch Shifts Focus

The recent move to release Daniel Jones on Friday, as noted by sports.yahoo.com, meant the final six games became a lame-duck stretch for Steichen, who now handed the offense to Anthony Richardson.

Indianapolis colts v houston texans houston texas november head coach
Photo: heavy.com

League sources expect Steichen to coach elsewhere in 2027, either as a head coach or an offensive coordinator, sports.yahoo.com reported.

The Colts’ decision to keep Jones through the trade deadline, despite Steichen’s earlier public support, heavy.com noted, shifted attention squarely onto the head coach.

Carlie Irsay-Gordon, the owner, reportedly had a big say in hiring Steichen, but profootballrumors.com suggests the team will evaluate him until the season ends before making final decisions.

The general consensus across the league points toward strong interest in Steichen for a head coaching role in 2027, profootballrumors.com reported.