The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development seized control of the Newark Housing Authority on Thursday, removing its entire board of commissioners after the agency failed to meet occupancy and financial benchmarks it agreed to two years ago.
HUD Assistant Secretary Benjamin Hobbs notified Executive Director Leonard Spicer and Board Chair Brian Logan in a Nov. 11 letter that the authority was in “substantial default” of a September 2024 recovery agreement, TAPinto reported.
The move transfers all board duties to Deputy Assistant Secretary Shylon Ferry and Associate Deputy Assistant Secretary Daniel Sherrod, both inside HUD’s Office of Public and Indian Housing. A board meeting scheduled for Friday was cancelled, and the authority’s website now lists the two federal officials as its governing body.
The takeover is the sharpest escalation yet in a federal intervention that began in 2023, when HUD declared the state’s largest public housing authority “troubled” over its finances and the physical condition of its apartments.
Since then, the agency — which operates 44 developments and administers Section 8 vouchers — has cycled through warnings, a recovery agreement, and now receivership under a provision of the Housing Act of 1937 that lets HUD step in when a local authority fails its obligations.
“NHA has not taken good faith efforts to substantially improve,” Hobbs wrote in the determination letter. “HUD considered NHA’s reported progress and claimed corrective efforts before determining whether further action is warranted. Those efforts do not outweigh the continued failure to meet benchmarks that NHA itself agreed to over two years ago.”
Where the benchmarks broke down
The recovery agreement required the authority to hit specific occupancy targets, improve its financial performance, and submit required financial data on time. HUD issued its first default determination on September 22, citing the occupancy failure alone. A November 5 supplemental letter added the financial performance and reporting deficiencies.

Federal regulations gave the authority ten calendar days after each letter to dispute the findings in writing. The Newark Housing Authority responded on October 2 and again on November 13, acknowledging it had not achieved the occupancy and financial performance requirements but arguing that metrics had improved given the circumstances and that the timing of the default determination was premature. HUD rejected both responses.
Under 24 CFR Section 902.75, a troubled authority must improve its Public Housing Assessment System score by at least 50 percent of the gap between its troubled score and the passing threshold within twelve months, and reach at least 60 percent of total available points within 24 months. The letter states the authority met neither benchmark, even when HUD credited it additional points for late fiscal year 2024 financial filings.
Baraka calls it a power play toward privatization
Newark Mayor Ras Baraka pushed back hard on Friday, framing the takeover as an ideological move to privatize the authority’s assets and vouchers rather than a necessary management correction.
“Completely privatizing the agency vouchers or assets is not the answer — because people with vouchers would then be overlooked and disenfranchised,” Baraka said in a statement. “Termination of the board and silencing tenants’ voices is not the answer, either. Nor is force-feeding the city an ideology that guts the low-income housing business by defunding it and compelling families to be dominated and victimized by market forces.”
Baraka traced the dysfunction to a decision by a previous board not to renew the prior executive director’s contract, then tying Spicer’s contract to getting the agency out of troubled status. Conflicts between that board and Spicer over process and timeline followed. Baraka said he met directly with HUD leadership when mediation failed, and was told that continued efforts to remove the executive director would trigger federal intervention.
“Removing the director is not grounds for a federal takeover of the authority and does not justify power plays to privatize it,” Baraka said.
Authority owes city $17 million and holds vacant land
The mayor’s statement laid out a broader indictment of the authority’s stewardship that goes beyond the federal benchmarks. The agency owes the city roughly $17 million, according to Baraka. It is the largest landowner in Newark with the most vacant and abandoned property — a fact that clashes with the administration’s “Keep Newark Affordable” push to develop housing quickly.
The authority also operates about 200 units refurbished and furnished by the city for transitional housing for formerly homeless residents. Baraka said he wants assurances that no tenants will be displaced and that the city’s inventory of units at all NHA properties will be maintained.
“The Housing Authority is also one of Newark’s largest evictors and shamefully holds the lion’s share of our housing violations,” Baraka said. “This serious, ongoing concern has been clearly expressed as our highest complaint multiple times — to board members, every executive director including this one, and HUD leadership.”
HUD says the goal is eventual local control
HUD Secretary Scott Turner said the department’s “decisive action demonstrates our commitment to holding public housing authorities accountable when they fall short of properly stewarding federal housing resources to better serve their communities,” Gothamist reported. The department said it intends to return the authority to local control eventually, but will retain control as long as needed to “restore the integrity” of operations.
Residents have been told that day-to-day operations and services — including Section 8 vouchers — will continue as usual under federal oversight. The authority posted a notice on its website Thursday night confirming that services would not be interrupted.
Federal receivership continues without fixed end date
The federal receivership has no fixed end date. Ferry and Sherrod now hold the board’s powers, and the ejected commissioners — Chairman Brian Logan, Vice Chairman Iman Daud-Haqq, South Ward Councilman Patrick Council, and commissioners Vivian Carter, Ashraf Latif and Linda Washington — have no remaining authority.
HUD’s letter cited its authority under 42 U.S.C. Section 1437d(j)(3)(A), the statutory receiver provision that allows the department to take possession and administer a defaulting housing authority.
For the thousands of Newark families living in the authority’s 44 developments or holding Section 8 vouchers, the immediate practical question is whether federal management can stabilize an agency that has been in formal distress for more than two years — and whether the city’s vision for those vacant properties survives the transition.
Worth a look