Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner Brody Harshbarger agreed on Nov. 9 to plead guilty to two wildlife violations, admitting he hunted without a tag and shot across a road during an illegal elk hunt last season, Outdoor Life reported.
The plea deal dismisses five other charges, including two counts of poaching, trespassing, motorized aid and failure to retrieve game. Harshbarger, who represents the Upper Snake region on the seven-member commission, had already filled his legal elk tag the weekend before he and another man, Eric Murphy, killed two bull elk — one antlerless and a 6×6 that fell on private property in Fremont County.
“Neither Brody Harshbarger nor Eric Murphy called the landowners to request permission to retrieve the six-point bull and did not make a reasonable effort to retrieve the six-point bull,” investigation documents obtained by the Idaho Capital Sun state.
A commissioner’s duty versus the record
Harshbarger was appointed by Gov. Brad Little in 2024 to a four-year term. The commission sets statewide seasons, bag limits and trapping regulations based on Idaho Department of Fish and Game science. Since a Citizens Against Poaching tip opened the case in December, Harshbarger has not attended commission meetings. His profile has been removed from the commission website, though he has not resigned and the governor has not removed him.

“The Governor’s office is aware of Commissioner Harshbarger’s plea agreement,” said Emily Callihan, Little’s spokeswoman. “Gov. Little will be working with the Idaho Department of Fish and Game and stakeholders in the coming days to ensure the responsibilities of the position are fulfilled.”
What the deal leaves out
Prosecutors dropped the most serious charges — poaching and trespass — in exchange for guilty pleas to hunting without a tag and shooting across a road. The expected penalty is a $500 fine and a one-year loss of hunting privileges. Sentencing is scheduled for Dec. 9.
Office has not announced replacement appointment
Little’s office has not said whether it will appoint a replacement before the commission’s next meeting.