Indiana Democrats File Petition for Special Election in Disputed Senate Race

“Every tool we have to get an accurate count we’re going to use,” said Evan Robbins, executive director of the Indiana Democratic Party.

Democrats filed a petition Wednesday asking the Indiana Recount Commission to order a special election in Senate District 45, escalating a fight over Republican Chris Garten’s 297-vote lead after equipment failures and poll-pad glitches plagued Election Day in Clark and Floyd counties.

The Clark County Democratic chair, Miguel Hampton, filed the contest one day after the Indiana Supreme Court lifted a lower court’s block and allowed Garten to be sworn in as Senate president pro tem.

Clark County Democrats sue to pause new Indiana Senate President Pro tem from taking office — WTHR

The district, which covers all of Clark County and part of Floyd County, shows Garten ahead of Democrat Nick Marshall by about two-thirds of a percentage point, according to unofficial totals cited by Indiana Capital Chronicle. Hampton’s petition argues that voting-equipment troubles at multiple sites “potentially make it impossible to audit and confirm who voted, whether each voter was registered, and whether each voter voted in the appropriate precinct,” and asks the commission to recount all 86 precincts rather than the four Jeffersonville precincts Garten himself requested.

The dispute centers on a mismatch between ballots cast and voters checked in. Garten, in a statement released Tuesday, said electronic pollbook data from the four precincts in question show 1,640 ballots cast compared with 1,612 voters recorded — a gap of 28 votes, well inside his 297-vote margin.

He attributed the difference to a technical issue with the pollbooks and noted that Republican and Democratic poll workers confirmed the replacement voting machine’s totals matched the original. “The Indiana Democratic Party is now making serious allegations about missing votes without providing evidence to substantiate those claims,” Garten said.

Republican state Sen. Chris Garten, left, and Democratic challenger Nick Marshall
Photo: ipm.org

The Clark County Election Board initially planned to hand-count ballots from the problematic polling place but reversed that decision at its Nov. 10 meeting. Democratic board member Andrew Steele acknowledged that “people have a right to file recounts.” The board’s resolution declared it had no authority to open sealed election materials and that it had sufficiently examined ballot sheets, poll pads and precinct results.

Indiana GOP Chairwoman Lana Keesling backed Garten, saying Democrats are “making unsupported accusations that damage trust in our elections” and that “there is no evidence of missing votes and no reason to believe the outcome will change.” Robbins, however, told WANE that the discrepancy between check-ins and ballots cast is unacceptable: “You can’t do that. We can’t have rounding errors in elections.”

A separate lawsuit filed Nov. 16 sought to block Garten’s swearing-in until a recount could proceed. That hearing was canceled after the assigned judge recused himself. The Indiana Supreme Court then lifted the temporary order blocking Garten’s oath, clearing the way for Senate Republicans to install him as leader Tuesday.

Laura Wilson, a political science professor at the University of Indianapolis, told WANE the situation creates a governance vacuum: “Whoever holds this office wields a tremendous amount of power and responsibility. If Garten loses this race, then it’s a real question mark in terms of who takes over.”

The Associated Press has not called the race. The Recount Commission has not yet set a hearing date.