Votes separated Republican Chris Garten and Democratic challenger Nick Marshall by 297 ballots on Tuesday setting off a legal battle that reached the state’s highest court.
Just hours after winning a temporary reprieve from the state’s highest court on Tuesday, newly sworn-in Senate President Pro Tempore Chris Garten announced he is petitioning for a full recount of his narrow victory in Senate District 45, according to Indiana Capital Chronicle.
Senate Republicans reconvened today for Organization Day, ceremonially beginning the 125th Indiana General Assembly. (1/3)
Vote tallies showed Garten secured 21,817 votes compared to 21,520 for Democrat Nick Marshall across Clark County and a portion of Floyd County, The Indiana Lawyer reported. But that margin immediately triggered scrutiny over voting machine tabulations and scanner malfunctions reported at Jeffersonville High School precincts on Election Day. Mike Braun.
Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton, Indiana Democratic Party Chair Karen Tallian, and Ninth District Democratic Party Chair Adam Dickey argued in a joint statement published by The Indiana Citizen that local election officials failed to adequately review those equipment glitches before certifying results.
Indiana Senate President Pro Tem @Sen_ChrisGarten on Indiana Supreme Court decision allowing him to be sworn in: “This is much bigger than Chris Garten. This is bigger than Republicans and this is bigger than Democrats…this is about the rule of law…I won that election by 297… pic.twitter.com/8B7HmNA9di”
“We will continue doing everything in our power to ensure these discrepancies are addressed and every legal vote was accurately counted,” the party leaders said.
Court Intervention and Constitutional Conflict
The dispute escalated Monday when Scott County Circuit Judge Jason Mount issued a temporary restraining order blocking the certification of Senate District 45 and barring Garten from taking his seat for Organization Day.
Mount’s order had prohibited Garten from “presenting himself to take the oath of office as, or to be seated as, the Senator from District 45.” Garten’s legal team, led by attorney James Bopp, filed an emergency appeal with the Indiana Supreme Court.

Chief Justice Loretta Rush and her fellow justices unanimously ruled in Garten’s favor on Tuesday, citing Article 4, Section 10 of the Indiana Constitution, which establishes that each house of the General Assembly is the sole judge of its members’ elections and qualifications. The court lifted the barrier preventing Garten from taking the oath of office while keeping the freeze on local vote certification in place.
“What we witnessed was an extraordinary attempt to use the judicial system to prevent the people from an entire Senate district from having their elected representative take office.”
said Garten, R-Charlestown, during a press conference following his swearing-in, where he characterized the Democratic legal challenge as “lawfare.”
“This is not simply a request to recount ballots.”
Garten, R-Charlestown, said following the recess of the Senate session.
“I believe that distinction matters.”
Garten, R-Charlestown, said.
“In my view, these actions created unnecessary election chaos and brought Indiana to the brink of constitutional confrontation over a disputed election.”
Garten said.
“And who would have paid the price?”
Garten said.
“This is bigger than Republicans, and it’s bigger than Democrats. This is about the Constitution.”
Garten said.
“As the candidate who’s the reported victor that’s being challenged, I am voluntarily requesting that the votes be recounted.”
he said.

Every lawful vote deserves to be counted accurately.”
Garten said.
While Garten welcomed transparency through a voluntarily requested recount, Senate Minority Leader Shelli Yoder, D-Bloomington, maintained that the fierce legal contest ultimately reinforces public trust. Yoder told The Indiana Citizen that the dispute demonstrates “that every vote counts, that votes do matter.”
“When you disagree, we can defend our convictions and we can still work together,” he said.
With the oath administered by Chief Justice Rush on Tuesday afternoon, Garten assumed his leadership post without opposition from either party. Yet, as petitions for an official recount move forward, the legal and constitutional standoff over Senate District 45 remains active.