Indianapolis Public Schools Proposes Closing Six Schools Amid Enrollment Decline and Budget Gap

Indianapolis Public Schools has lost roughly a third of its enrollment over the past decade, pushing the student count below 20,000 and triggering a proposal to shutter six schools after this academic year.

The administration unveiled the consolidation plan at a Tuesday agenda review session, setting up a board vote on December 8, Chalkbeat reported. Superintendent Aleesia Johnson acknowledged the weight of the moment. “Change of this magnitude is never easy,” she said at the meeting.

The closures would take effect next summer, forcing families to recalibrate plans for the 2027-28 school year before the first enrollment window closes December 18. If approved, the move would close more schools than any action since the district shut six buildings under its 2023 Rebuilding Stronger plan.

IPS proposes closing 6 school buildings, merging several schools in restructuring plan — WTHR

The schools slated for closure are Ralph Waldo Emerson School 58, Robert Lee Frost School 106, Benjamin Harrison School 2, Longfellow Middle School, Frederick Douglass School 19, and James A. Garfield School 31. Each would merge into a receiving school that retains specific instructional models — International Baccalaureate at Charity Dye School 27 and Howe Middle School, Reggio-inspired at Eliza Blaker School 55, Exploratory at Christian Park School 82, and STEM at Eleanor Skillen School 34.

Enrollment collapse and charter growth drive the deficit

The district has watched its enrollment erode for years while independent charters and Innovation Network schools have expanded. Combined enrollment in those sectors now exceeds the count in IPS-run schools, a crossover that accelerates the financial strain. Even the passage of a $95 million property-tax referendum on November 3 — money designated for both district and charter operations — could not close a $20 million budget gap that Johnson said necessitates the cuts.

The timing carries an added urgency. In 2028, the Indianapolis Public Education Corporation assumes control of buildings and transportation for IPS and charter schools within the district’s boundaries.

Johnson told the board the district has a narrow window to sell the soon-to-be-vacant properties while it still holds the deeds and before the state’s dollar-building law — which requires districts to offer unused schools to charters for $1 — takes full effect for IPS. Proceeds from those sales would feed the operating budget.

A faster process than 2023, and schools closing twice

Four years ago, the district spent months gathering public input before the board adopted Rebuilding Stronger. This cycle moves at a sprint: the board received the proposal this week and could vote in three weeks.

The compressed timeline has drawn scrutiny, particularly because two schools on the current list — Frederick Douglass School 19 and Robert Lee Frost School 106 — absorbed displaced students during the 2023 round. Families there face a second disruption in as many cycles.

Johnson said the district sought to ensure receiving schools could accommodate the incoming students. Families who selected the closing schools during the current enrollment window will be contacted directly, and the district plans to maintain existing enrollment zones and transportation eligibility for those who choose an alternative within their zone.

Elementary high-ability program moves to Benjamin Harrison

The plan reshuffles more than students. The elementary high-ability program moves from Merle Sidener Academy 59 to the Benjamin Harrison School 2 building, which Johnson described as more centrally located.

Margaret McFarland Learning Academy and Positive Supports Academy will relocate to the James A. Garfield School 31 building, preserving their specialized services for students with disabilities and alternative-education needs. Meanwhile, the new Joyce Kilmer 69 facility under construction will open as the CITY Career Center, a centralized vocational hub.

District asserts control amid structural pressure

IPS has recently moved to reassert authority in adjacent fights. The district withdrew from the universal Enroll Indy system in favor of a PowerSchool-run platform, a decision that angered charter operators who relied on the common portal.

At the same time, leaders are pushing to renegotiate Innovation Network contracts to reflect what they say is the true cost of district-provided services. Neither maneuver solves the structural enrollment decline, but both show a district trying to shore up its finances before the 2028 governance change.

The board is expected to take action on the closure plan December 8.