Inter Miami face elimination from the MLS Cup playoffs after a 3-0 home defeat to Columbus Crew left the defending champions on the brink in their best-of-three series, with the decisive Game 2 set for Friday in Ohio.
The reigning MLS Cup winners were reduced to 10 men before the flashpoint that has dominated post-match scrutiny. In first-half stoppage time, with Miami trailing 1-0, Lionel Messi hurled a throw-in into the face of Columbus forward Gonzalo Tapia from close range. Referee Allen Chapman cautioned both players, but Columbus head coach Laurent Courtois said the Argentina captain should have been dismissed.
“Everybody knows that he deserved more than a yellow card,” Courtois told reporters after the match. “It’s just really sad.” ESPN reported Courtois added that the situation warranted league review.
Chapman defended his decision to a pool reporter, stating: “The force used was negligible and the offense did not reach the level of violent conduct.” The Guardian noted the referee’s explanation cited the threshold for a red-card offense under the laws of the game.
Messi, who collected his sixth yellow card of the 2026 MLS season on the play, had been presented with the Golden Boot before kickoff after scoring 26 goals and adding 17 assists in the regular season.
ESPN confirmed the tally made him the first player to win the award in consecutive seasons.
Inter Miami coach Cristian “Kily” González downplayed the incident. “The card doesn’t change much,” he said in his postgame news conference. “The referee saw a yellow and that is it, we can’t blame the referee. Sometimes they make mistakes, sometimes they don’t like each one of us and we have to accept it.” Al Jazeera reported González’s remarks.
Tapia, who scored twice in the victory, declined to criticize the call.
“I don’t know if it’s a red card, but I am not the referee to say. It stays there,” he told reporters. ESPN quoted the Chilean forward.
The result means seventh-seeded Columbus, the 2023 champions, can advance to the conference semi-finals with a win in Game 2 on Friday.
Miami must win to force a third match back at Nu Stadium.
“Pressure? Of course there is pressure,” Miami midfielder Casemiro said. “Inter Miami always plays to win and we know if we lose the next game we are out.” ESPN reported his comments.
González stresses character test after heavy defeat
Miami head coach Cristian “Kily” González acknowledged the team produced a poor display, telling reporters that nothing went right and Miami effectively created chances for Columbus. He said the side must learn quickly because a loss in Friday’s Game 2 would end their season. González framed the challenge as a test of character and expressed confidence his squad has it, according to The Guardian.
Lionel Messi takes a throw-in off Gonzalo Tapia's face pic.twitter.com/jX3tTuojHe
Al Jazeera reported González adding that the team did not produce the great performance it had hoped for and that everything went wrong. He insisted the group has to use the experience to improve before the decisive match in Ohio.
Courtois calls incident sad and urges league review
Columbus head coach Laurent Courtois said the Messi throw-in episode was “just really sad” and that everybody knows the Argentina captain deserved more than a yellow card.

The Guardian and Al Jazeera both quoted Courtois repeating that Messi should have been sent off. The Al Jazeera account noted Courtois made the remarks in his postgame news conference.
Chapman defends decision citing negligible force
The Guardian and Al Jazeera each carried Chapman’s explanation, with Al Jazeera quoting the exact phrasing about negligible force.
Al Jazeera also cited International Football Association Board Law 12, which states the thrower could be sent off for violent conduct if excessive force is used, but both players may be cautioned for unsporting behaviour.