On Saturday, the New York Mets Secured Center Fielder A.J. Ewing to an Eight-Year

On Saturday, the New York Mets secured center fielder A.J. Ewing to an eight-year, $95 million contract extension.

Extending Carson Benge

Following that deal, attention turns to whether the Mets might lock up outfielder Carson Benge and starting pitcher Nolan McLean. The team has historically been reticent to engage on extensions, and president of baseball operations David Stearns is generally less inclined to extend younger players than many peers. Yet the Ewing agreement establishes a framework that could apply across the core.

For Benge, a ceiling can be found in the Chicago Cubs’ spring extension with Pete Crow-Armstrong ahead of his MVP season. Crow-Armstrong secured $115 million over six years after a 5.3-WAR campaign, valuing free-agent years at about $30 million per season. Ewing’s deal values his free-agent years at roughly $25 million per season, providing a baseline floor for Benge.

New York Mets LOCK UP A.J. Ewing Long-Term — Locked On Mets

Writing on sports.yahoo.com, The Athletic’s Tim Britton projected it would take an eight-year, $117.5 million deal to keep Benge in Queens. That projection factors in buying out two years of free agency at $27.5 million per year alongside a club option at $30 million with a $2.5 million buyout.

“If we buy out two years of free agency at Ewing’s rate of $25 million apiece, you get a seven-year, $85 million deal for Benge,” wrote Britton. “Do the same at Crow-Armstrong’s rate of $30 million apiece, and it’s seven for $95 million. I like splitting the difference with a twist. Let’s add a third year to take Benge through his age-31 season and pair his deal with Ewing’s. We’ll up the free-agent valuation to $27.5 million. That would push Benge to eight years worth $117.5 million. The Mets are unlikely to do the deal without a club option, so you can add one in there at $30 million with a $2.5 million buyout.”

Benge hit 20 home runs and posted a .776 OPS in his rookie season, while risingapple.com noted he finished as the National League Rookie of the Year runner-up to Sal Stewart of the Cincinnati Reds in 2026 with a 4.3 bWAR and 22 stolen bases.

Photo: sports.yahoo.com

Projecting Potential Extensions for Benge

Rising Apple projected that Carson Benge will receive an eight-year deal worth a minimum of $120 million following the agreement with A.J. Ewing.

According to Rising Apple, Benge recorded 1 Outs Above Average in right field and ranked in the 99th percentile for arm strength. Successfully locking him down would secure both him and Ewing as homegrown outfielders for the foreseeable future.

Forecasting a Deal for McLean

Rising Apple predicted that starting pitcher Nolan McLean will receive a seven-year deal worth $168 million. That agreement would carry a $24 million average annual value and buy out his existing club control while adding two more years beyond it.

Securing McLean to a long-term contract could potentially pair him with two-time Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal—should the team land him in free agency—to lead the rotation for many years, as reported by Rising Apple. Such a contract would also represent a bargain compared to the massive deal Skubal is positioned to receive.

Photo: risingapple.com

Valuing Nolan McLean

A potential extension for pitcher Nolan McLean carries distinct challenges due to pitcher injury risk and fewer comparable precedents. Recent top-tier deals include Spencer Strider’s six-year, $75 million extension with the Atlanta Braves and Chase Burns’s seven-year, $105 million extension with the Cincinnati Reds.

As president of baseball operations for the New York Mets since 2024, David Stearns has a long-standing reputation for caution regarding long-term commitments.

Earlier in his executive career, while serving as assistant general manager of the Houston Astros from 2012 to 2015, and subsequently as general manager and later president of baseball operations for the Milwaukee Brewers from 2015 to 2022, he frequently avoided locking up younger talent early. Instead, his historical approach favored retaining club control through arbitration and avoiding the financial risks of premature extensions.

While this background highlights a strict adherence to fiscal caution, the A.J. Ewing agreement does not necessarily represent a permanent philosophical pivot for Stearns.

Starting pitchers generally earn less in arbitration than position players, setting lower pre-free-agency earnings estimates.