Ahwatukee residents will file an $11 million notice of claim against the City of Phoenix on Friday, alleging the city let a massive data center proceed under expired approvals while ignoring updated zoning rules.
The filing targets the Menlo Digital campus under construction near 48th Street and Thistle Landing Drive, a nearly 1-million-square-foot project neighbors say has already blanketed their streets in dust, diesel fumes and round-the-clock noise. Attorney Anthony Ramirez, representing the Ahwatukee Community Alliance, said the claim splits the damages: $1 million for lost property value and $10 million for what residents describe as ongoing nuisance conditions.
“It was kind of a ‘shush’ deal,” Karin Vigesaa told 12News at a September protest, capturing the frustration that the project advanced with little public awareness until heavy equipment arrived. “There’s 80,000 people that live in Ahwatukee, and I don’t even think a lot of them know about what’s going on here.”
The zoning fight
The dispute hinges on timing. Phoenix rezoned the 38-acre parcel in 1996, a classification the city says permits data centers by right. Menlo Digital bought the land in 2015 and submitted plans years later, securing preliminary site plan approval before the City Council adopted a new data center ordinance last year that imposed stricter setbacks, noise limits and environmental review requirements.
Because the project was approved before that ordinance took effect, the city maintains it is not retroactive and the older rules govern.

Ramirez argues the preliminary approval had lapsed, meaning the developer should have been forced to comply with the new standards. He has also filed ethics complaints against Vice Mayor Kesha Hodge-Washington and Councilmember Kevin Robinson over campaign contributions from executives linked to Menlo Digital.
Construction impacts
For homeowners like Annette Poleon, who has lived in her 1993-built house off South 48th Street for three decades, the impact is daily and visceral. “The worst part became when they started digging. I can’t describe it. I mean, if you can picture a monsoon dust storm,” Poleon told AZFamily.
She works from home and says the noise starts before the permitted 5 a.m. summer start time; the city confirmed it received complaints about early work.
Ana Marshall, another neighbor, questioned the site choice: “Why did you build it so close to residential area? There’s so much land and dirt around here. You are telling me the city of Phoenix could not negotiate moving this out a mile out?” The city’s position is that the zoning was set decades ago and the project complied with the rules in place when it was approved.
Health and environmental concerns
No health or environmental impact studies were conducted for the project; the city confirmed they were not required under the old zoning. The campus plan includes more than 100 diesel generators and an on-site electrical substation, raising fears of persistent air and noise pollution once the facility is operational.
“I don’t know that there is a really a way to coexist this close,” Marshall said. “There’s just too much of industrial pollution, noise and diesel pollution that will be unavoidable.”
Poleon, who works in IT implementation, emphasized she is not opposed to data centers broadly. “I am not against data centers. I am in IT. I do implementation of IT solutions. What I’m against are data centers in the middle of neighborhoods,” she said.

State scrutiny escalates
The conflict has drawn state-level attention. Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes held a town hall on data centers earlier this month and announced her office would investigate the Menlo Digital project and consider a nuisance lawsuit, AZFamily reported. Neighbors have formed a nonprofit, Stop the Data Center in Ahwatukee, and continue to hold regular meetings.
Ramirez plans to announce the notice of claim at 11 a.m. Friday. The City of Phoenix has not yet responded to requests for comment on the filing.