Jeremiah Smith Reclaims Heisman Favorite Status at Minus Odds as Quarterback Contenders Fade

Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith has reclaimed his spot as the odds-on favorite for the 2026 Heisman Trophy, moving to minus-odds on major sportsbooks after a second straight 100-yard performance.

Smith caught 11 passes for 117 yards and a touchdown in the Buckeyes’ 28-19 win over Northwestern on Saturday, pushing his season totals to 80 receptions for 1,317 yards and 15 scores. The performance moved his betting line to -144 on DraftKings and -140 on FanDuel, implying a 58-to-59 percent probability of winning the award, depending on the sportsbook.

The race has been a revolving door of quarterback narratives all season. Notre Dame’s CJ Carr briefly seized the favorite role after a statement win over Miami in Week 10, only to slip back to fourth in the odds following an efficient but unspectacular outing against Boston College. Miami’s Darian Mensah and Utah’s Devon Dampier now sit second and third, respectively, behind Smith.

The quarterback injury that reshaped the race

Smith’s candidacy took a hit when starting quarterback Julian Sayin went down with an injury, forcing backup Luke Fahey into the lineup. The Buckeyes have gone 1-2 in Fahey’s three starts, and the team already has three regular-season losses for the first time since 2011.

Yet Smith’s production hasn’t collapsed; he has hauled in 28 catches for 333 yards and three touchdowns over those three games. He is currently on pace for 96 catches, 1,580 yards and 18 touchdowns.

Northwestern v Ohio State
Photo: nbcsports.com

“He’s an awesome receiver, but quarterbacks usually win,” a summary of preseason skepticism noted. “As the season went on, those quarterbacks fell off… Then the narrative became more like ‘Wow, this guy is really awesome, and none of the quarterbacks are special this year.’”

Mensah and Dampier apply pressure

Miami’s Darian Mensah sits at +340 to +350 after a big game in a 36-25 win against Duke, where he completed 30 of 41 passes for 382 yards and a TD. The junior has a chance to win back-to-back ACC titles and give Miami their first conference championship.

Ohio State still has Nebraska and Michigan remaining on the docket, and while the Buckeyes are facing an uphill battle to make the College Football Playoff, Smith’s numbers speak for themselves even with the Buckeyes forced to use a backup quarterback.

Utah’s Devon Dampier, listed at +550 to +720, is making a late push. The senior accounted for four total touchdowns in a 40-39 win at Arizona, throwing for 204 yards and rushing for another 100 on 14 carries.

He has led the Utes to a 10-0 record with wins over No. 9 BYU, No. 14 Houston and No. 23 Arizona. Should Utah reach 13-0, Dampier appears to be a safe pick to at least get to New York as a finalist.

Carr’s case stalls on soft schedule

CJ Carr’s Heisman moment arrived in a first half against Miami, but the Irish’s performance in a 41-7 rout of Boston College wasn’t enough to keep him in the top spot.

He finished 20-of-28 for 217 yards and two touchdowns, numbers that failed to move the needle in his direction. Notre Dame hosts SMU for its home finale this weekend, then travels to Syracuse before their revenge tour begins in the college football playoff. He sits at +1000 to +1100.

Jeremiah Smith Reclaims Heisman Favorite Status at Minus Odds as Quarterback Contenders Fade
Photo: si.com

History favors the finalist stage

The Buckeyes close the regular season at Nebraska and at home against Michigan — two of the top 10 defenses in college football. “Just how bad can Ohio State finish before it matters?” one report asked.

Georgia’s Gunner Stockton (+2500) is an outsider in fifth. Oklahoma State’s Drew Mestemaker fell out of the conversation after Texas Tech routed Oklahoma State, ending his run at the trophy.

“Smith is the best player, but the Heisman Trophy’s criteria are open-ended: it’s awarded to the most outstanding player in college football. If Smith falls below that mark, there are a few players who could elevate themselves in the final weeks.”

With two weeks remaining, the market has settled on a clear top four.