Judge Bars Removal, Demands Legal Basis for Warrantless Arrest of 18-Year-old in Maine

Federal agents detained an 18-year-old Ecuadorian man during a traffic stop in Livermore Falls on Monday despite possessing no warrant and knowing the man held special immigrant status, The Portland Press Herald reported.

The man, who uses a pseudonym in court filings, entered the United States in 2024 as an unaccompanied minor. He subsequently received special immigrant juvenile status, a legal classification designated for undocumented immigrants under 21 who have suffered abuse, neglect, or abandonment by a parent.

His detention occurred after a Border Patrol agent pulled over a van carrying eight passengers because the vehicle featured Massachusetts license plates, no markings, and a ladder rack. The agent wrote in an incident report that vans matching this description frequently transport undocumented workers from Massachusetts to work sites in Maine.

Agent Arrests Six Passengers Without Warrant

During the stop, the agent questioned each occupant about their citizenship before deciding to arrest six of the passengers without a warrant. While being questioned, the 18-year-old called his brother in Rhode Island. Court documents show the brother informed agents of the man’s special immigrant status.

“It appeared [he] was not in removal proceedings.”

That was what the officer told the man’s brother, according to court documents. The agent then said that the man would be detained nonetheless.

Judge Bars Removal, Demands Legal Basis for Warrantless Arrest of 18-Year-old in Maine
Photo: sunjournal.com

Some of the arrested individuals were taken to the U.S. Customs and Border Protection station in Rangeley. Others, including the 18-year-old, were brought to the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Scarborough.

Court documents filed Tuesday indicate that CBP drafted an administrative warrant after the traffic stop, which was signed by immigration officials rather than a judge. Agents served the warrant after the man arrived at the ICE facility.

Judge Bars Removal but Transfer Proceeds

Because both the initial traffic stop and subsequent detention occurred without a warrant, U.S. District Judge Stacey Neumann ordered ICE on Monday not to remove the man from Maine. The judge also demanded that the government provide a legal basis for his arrest.

However, after being served with the administrative warrant in Scarborough, the man was transferred to a detention center in Rhode Island on Monday evening. Assistant U.S. Attorney Trevor Taniguchi, representing ICE and CBP, wrote in court records that agents were notified of the judge’s order while the man was already en route.

Immigration Agents Ordered to Explain Warrantless Arrest in Maine Traffic Stop
Photo: maineeexpres.com

Taniguchi argued that the man was arrested under the authority of a valid arrest warrant and asserted that the legality of the initial arrest is irrelevant. He maintained that the court must focus solely on the lawfulness of the current detention.

“The detention is lawful because [the man] is now in removal proceedings, and those proceedings are not likely to be terminated due to the alleged arrest/processing violation.”

Taniguchi wrote this in court filings on Tuesday. The Maine Immigrants’ Rights Coalition, which monitors ICE detentions across the state, said that similar warrantless arrests and dragnet enforcement tactics have grown increasingly frequent during President Donald Trump’s immigration crackdown.

“Unfortunately, this level of detail often doesn’t have a chance to surface in the public because the rush to deport coupled with the absence of universal representation means many similar cases don’t make it in front of judges.”

Panagioti Tsolkas, a spokesperson for the Maine Immigrants’ Rights Coalition, told The Portland Press Herald.

Attorney Files Habeas Petition Challenging Arrest

Talia Rothstein, the attorney representing the 18-year-old, declined to comment on the case. Rothstein filed a habeas corpus petition on Monday challenging the constitutionality of the arrest.

According to the petition, the young man has no known criminal history in the United States or in Ecuador. He arrived in America at age 16 to escape his father, who physically and psychologically abused him in a home lacking warm water, a shower, and heat.

About six months after his arrival, a Massachusetts state court judge ruled that he had suffered abuse and neglect. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services subsequently granted him special immigrant juvenile status to place him on a path toward lawful permanent residency.

“The U.S. government promised him that he would be given a meaningful path to [lawful permanent resident] status in this country. That came with the expectation that he could build a life here without risking arbitrary arrest, detention and removal.”

The petition stated these details regarding the promises made to the youth. Taniguchi countered in court filings that special juvenile status is not a lawful immigration status, but rather a classification, and stated the man remains in removal proceedings.