A Southern Indiana judge has granted a temporary restraining order preventing Republican state Sen. Chris Garten from being seated to a new term this week for District 45.
The legal halt arrives as the local Democratic Party moves to challenge his victory following disputes over uncounted ballots. Special Judge Jason Mount of Scott County issued the order, which also blocks Clark County from certifying results for both the Indiana Senate District 45 race and the contest for Clark County Auditor.
The intervention stems from a lawsuit filed on Monday by the local party. The complaint asks for a preliminary injunction “barring [Garten] from being sworn in or seated until the Recount Commission makes its final determination,” according to a news release.
Garten secured a victory by 447 votes over Democratic challenger Nick Marshall in Clark County, which represents the largest area of the district. Meanwhile, Marshall edged out Garten in Floyd County, a smaller portion of the district. In the auditor’s race, Republican Monty Snelling received 257 more votes than Democrat Antonio Veals.
The conflict traces back to a 2-1 vote by the Clark County Election Board last week. The board declined to count ballots from four precincts at the Jeffersonville High School polling place due to technical issues encountered on Election Day.
“The Clark County Election Board left us with no other option but to resolve this issue in the courts,” Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton, Indiana Democratic Party Chair Karen Tallian and 9th District Indiana Democratic Party Chair Adam Dickey said in a joint statement on Monday.
The lawsuit seeks judicial review of an election board resolution adopted on November 10. According to a news release, the board “found that it had examined the ballot sheets, poll pads and precinct results, that the information was reconciled, and that it had no authority to open the ballot containers.”
Andy Steele, the Democratic member on the three-person board, voted against that resolution. He “acknowledged on the record that the resolution adopted a false narrative.”
Garten did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Monday. In a statement released last week, he dismissed the Democrats’ ballot concerns as “political theater.”
The restraining order specifically bars Garten from “presenting himself to take the oath of office as, or to be seated as, the Senator from District 45.” A hearing on the preliminary injunction is scheduled for Wednesday.
The lawsuit names Garten, Clerk Ryan Lynch—who sits on the election board—and the Clark County Election Board as respondents. Angela Cornett, the Clark County Voter Registration election administrator, stated late Monday afternoon that while the deadline to certify votes and transmit information to the state fell on Monday, the results remained uncertified.
The legislature meets for Organization Day on Tuesday. That’s when elected officials get sworn in. The Indiana Senate Majority Caucus recently tapped Garten to serve as Senate President Pro Tem.
Candidates face a deadline of Tuesday at noon to file recount petitions, while parties have until Friday to file their own petitions.
Earlier coverage: Blocks Garten From Being Sworn In as Indiana Senate Leader