Supreme Court Upholds Maryland Gun Restrictions in Sensitive Places

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to intervene in a legal battle over Maryland’s 2023 gun control law, effectively allowing the state to maintain its current restrictions on carrying firearms in so-called “sensitive places.”

By refusing to hear the appeal in Novotny v. Moore, the high court left intact a January ruling from the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that had upheld most of the state’s 2023 law.

The decision leaves in place a broad framework of constraints that limit where residents may carry weapons for self-defense. These locations include state parks, amusement parks, mass transit systems, and properties hosting vulnerable populations, such as daycare facilities, schools, and hospitals.

The High Court’s Skepticism

While the court chose not to take the case, the move was not met with total silence from the bench. Justice Clarence Thomas issued a separate statement expressing personal skepticism regarding whether each portion of the Maryland law restricting gun-carrying is consistent with Second Amendment principles.

However, he clarified that he agreed with the court’s decision to reject the case, noting that the breadth of the petitioners’ challenge would complicate the court’s review.

Supreme Court Leaves Maryland's Gun-Free 'Sensitive Places' Law in Place; Thomas Signals Doubts — The Daily Fallout

For gun-rights advocates, the refusal to hear the case is a disappointment. Bill Sack, the senior director of legal operations at the Second Amendment Foundation, voiced his frustration with the outcome. “Maryland has extinguished the Second Amendment rights of its residents by creating multiple categories of so-called sensitive places,” Sack wrote.

Despite the disappointment, the organization remains focused on other legal avenues. Sack pointed to a narrower pending case concerning New York’s sensitive places carry ban in public parks as a potential vehicle for future litigation. “We are encouraged, however, with Justice Thomas’ statement in which he casts serious doubt as to the constitutionality of laws like Maryland’s,” he added.

Supreme Court Declines to Hear Maryland ‘Sensitive Places’ Gun Case — The Center Right Brief

Fragmented Legal Systems

The Maryland Attorney General’s Office did not immediately respond to a request for comment Monday.

The legal friction extends beyond the state-level law. Just one week prior to the Supreme Court’s announcement, a U.S. District Court judge in Maryland upheld a similar ordinance from Montgomery County, dismissing a challenge that had been brought forward by the U.S. Justice Department.

Groups like Maryland Shall Issue, a petitioner in the case, said their work continues. In a statement released following the court’s order, the group described the decision as a disappointment but pledged to continue challenging legislation they argue is “designed for no other reason than to eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense.”

The Unresolved Question of “Sensitive Places”

The core of the dispute rests on how far states can go in designating public spaces as off-limits to firearm carry. While the justices have allowed Maryland’s specific law to stand for now, the legal community is watching closely to see if the court will eventually grant certiorari to a different case.