Judge Dismisses Homicide Case Against Austin Clowes Without Prejudice

“This is a good result for him. However, it is not the result we sought,” defense attorney Herman Watson said after a Gallatin County judge dismissed the deliberate homicide charge against Austin Clowes on Monday, stopping a trial that had been set to begin November 30.

District Judge John Brown dismissed the case without prejudice at the request of the Montana Attorney General’s Office, which took over prosecution from Gallatin County. The state asked to dismiss or delay the trial five days after Brown barred prosecutors from presenting DNA results they had acknowledged were the key link between Clowes and the victim, Steven Kilwein, NonStop Local Montana reported.

Kilwein, 79, was found dead inside his Bozeman home in June 2021. An autopsy determined he died from multiple chop-type injuries. A cellphone found in Kilwein’s front yard was later traced to Clowes, who was arrested and charged in 2025. He pleaded not guilty.

Montana prosecutors seek dismissal or delay in 2021 Bozeman homicide case
Photo: kxlf.com

The ruling leaves the Kilwein family without a resolution and gives the state time to pursue additional DNA testing.

The defense objected to any delay and asked that a dismissal be with prejudice, which would bar refiling. Watson Law Office said in a statement that Clowes “demanded a speedy trial to clear his name before a jury” and was ready for the November 30 start date.

The defense also alleged that the state’s charging affidavit falsely claimed an unknown male DNA profile was recovered from Kilwein’s fingernails, when the only profile found was Kilwein’s own — a fact the state’s own analyst confirmed under oath in September.

“The State has had the laboratory report saying so since November 2025. Eight months later, it relied on the same affidavit again to amend the charge,” the defense statement said. “Our motion asking the Court to address those statements was still pending when the case was dismissed.”

Prosecutors said they had contacted two private forensic laboratories about additional analysis and needed more time to present their case, according to court filings cited by KXLF. The defense countered that the state’s motion came only after the court excluded its primary DNA evidence.

Prosecutors request postponement or dismissal for trial in 2021 Bozeman homicide case
Photo: newsbreak.com

Because the dismissal is without prejudice, the state may refile the same charge. Watson Law Office said it is reviewing the order and weighing options, including asking the Montana Supreme Court to make the result permanent.

“Austin has lived under this accusation for sixteen months. He is presumed innocent, as he has been from the start,” the defense statement said. “This community deserves an investigation that follows the evidence. Our sympathy remains with the Kilwein family, who also deserve justice.”

The next step rests with the Attorney General’s Office, which has not announced whether it will seek a new indictment.