Judge Grants Injunction Requiring Eligibility Certification for Godfrey

“RJ is such a good individual, and he’s deserving of this opportunity,” Arizona coach Tommy Lloyd said Tuesday after a Pima County Superior Court judge cleared the path for forward RJ Godfrey to play this season.

Judge Jeffrey Bergin granted a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction requiring the Arizona Board of Regents and the university to certify Godfrey’s eligibility under the NCAA’s Bylaw 12.6, the “5 for 5” model published in the association’s 2026-27 manual last August. The ruling opens the door for Godfrey to make his Wildcats debut Wednesday night when No. 12 Arizona hosts No. 3 UConn at ALKEME Arena.

Godfrey, a transfer who spent three seasons at Clemson and one at Georgia, had exhausted four years of eligibility entering 2026-27. The NCAA has publicly maintained that the “5 for 5” provision does not apply to athletes who began college in the fall of 2022, a stance that contradicts the text of its own recently published manual.

That discrepancy has fueled a wave of successful lawsuits across the Big 12, where 22 players on 13 teams have won eligibility via court order. Godfrey was the only one in that group still sidelined.

Northern Arizona v Arizona
Photo: azdesertswarm.com

Rather than sue the NCAA directly — the route taken in every other “5 for 5” case — Godfrey’s attorneys, Ryan Downton and Ali Farhang, sued the Arizona Board of Regents for breach of contract, arguing the board failed to follow the NCAA manual’s eligibility certification language.

ABOR’s two attorneys declined to question witnesses and issued a brief statement supporting Godfrey’s case. Athletic director Desiree Reed-Francois, subpoenaed but absent, submitted an affidavit in support that was read into the record.

Teammates Derek Dixon and Ivan Kharchenkov testified that Godfrey’s absence had forced starters into heavier minutes. Lloyd told the court Godfrey was recruited to be the starting power forward and would not steal development reps from younger players.

Nearly the entire team and coaching staff attended the hearing, with several players seated in the jury box. “It just reminds me of what great guys we have and what a great culture that we have in our program and just how special it is to be at Arizona basketball,” Lloyd said.

Tommy Lloyd speaks out on Godfrey's Eligibility — KGUN9

The injunction does not guarantee Godfrey suits up against the Huskies. The NCAA — not a named party in the suit — could still appeal or pursue a suspension tied to Godfrey’s participation in a Final Four all-star game and his brief signing with an agent.

Godfrey testified he received no pay for the game, only an advance for training expenses tied to a pro pursuit, and that he has since repaid the money. If a suspension is imposed, the hope is that the international exhibitions in Lithuania, three preseason games and the first four regular-season contests already missed will count as time served.

“I’m excited to kind of move forward, but I always know there’s something else coming,” Godfrey said.

Judge Grants Injunction Requiring Eligibility Certification for Godfrey
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

Meanwhile, Lloyd is juggling on-court adjustments ahead of the UConn showdown. After center Motiejus Krivas operated away from the basket in the second half of Friday’s win at Auburn — a freelance decision Lloyd praised as “good players making good basketball plays” — the coach made clear he still prefers Krivas near the rim.

“I wouldn’t expect to see Mo turn into Jokic overnight. I think we still want Mo in the paint throwing in jump hooks,” Lloyd said.

Tipoff against UConn is set for Wednesday at McKale Center. The written order from Judge Bergin is expected to be formally issued later Tuesday.