The Senate confirmed Daniel Domenico to the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday by a 51-46 vote, giving President Donald Trump a third appointee on the Denver-based bench that shapes federal law across six Western states.
Colorado’s two Democratic senators, Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper, voted against the nomination. Both cited Domenico’s refusal during a June Judiciary Committee hearing to say who won the 2020 presidential election and a district court ruling this year that the federal government can detain immigrants without a bond hearing — a position at odds with every other Colorado federal judge.
By a vote of 51-46, the #Senate confirmed the nomination of Daniel Desmond Domenico to be United States Circuit Judge for the Tenth Circuit. This was a party-line vote with Senators Moody, Murphy, and Risch did not vote.
“An appellate-level role on the federal circuit carries broader responsibility and greater consequence, making these concerns particularly significant,” Bennet said in a statement. “At a time when the Trump Administration has spent years undermining the rule of law and eroding the independence of the federal courts, I cannot support elevating Judge Domenico to the Tenth Circuit.”
Hickenlooper’s office said Domenico’s record and hearing responses “were troubling and inconsistent with the high standards we should expect from federal judges,” according to a spokesperson.
The confirmation fills the seat left by Judge Timothy Tymkovich, who moved to senior status this year. Domenico clerked for Tymkovich in 2003. Trump first nominated him to the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado in 2017; he served as chief judge of that court briefly in 2026 before the appeals court nomination in May.
Before the federal bench, Domenico was Colorado’s solicitor general, arguing cases before the U.S. Supreme Court, the 10th Circuit and the Colorado Supreme Court across three gubernatorial administrations. In 2022, he carried the fourth-largest backlog of pending motions among all federal district and magistrate judges nationwide.

“Domenico declined to answer when a senator on the committee asked him who won the 2020 election,” a spokesperson for Hickenlooper said. “That refusal and his record on immigration were troubling and inconsistent with the high standards we should expect from federal judges.”
The 10th Circuit hears appeals from federal district courts in Colorado, Oklahoma, Kansas, New Mexico, Wyoming and Utah, plus portions of Yellowstone National Park in Montana and Idaho. Its rulings can be appealed only to the U.S. Supreme Court. Trump’s two prior appointees to the court are Judges Allison Eid and Joel Carson, both confirmed during his first term.
Trump will now nominate a replacement for Domenico’s district court seat. Home-state senators traditionally play a leading role in recommending district court nominees.
51-27: Senate along party lines advanced the nomination of U. S. District Court chief judge for Colorado Daniel Domenico to serve a lifetime appointment on the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, which hears appeals from CO, KS, NM, OK, UT & WY district courts. Senators confirmed him… https://t.co/QNINAr6VWk
The vote fell largely along party lines. Republicans emphasized Domenico’s experience as solicitor general and his seven years on the district court. Democrats argued that his bond-hearing ruling and his silence on the 2020 election outcome showed an ideological approach incompatible with the circuit's broader authority.
Domenico’s confirmation comes as the 119th Congress processes a slate of Trump judicial nominees before the August recess. The Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on his nomination was held June 24, 2026.