Julia O’Malley: Anchorage Grocers Use Electronic Tags; One Chain Gets 35% Net Income From Data

Anchorage's three major grocery chains use electronic shelf tags for real-time pricing and data harvesting, with one company deriving over 35 percent of net income from selling that data.

In a column for her Substack An Alaska Life, Julia O’Malley argues that Anchorage’s three major grocery chains have rolled out electronic shelf tags that enable real-time price changes while harvesting shopper data through discount apps.

The shift matters because Alaska households already pay more for groceries than any state except Hawaii, and the new technology could let retailers charge different prices for the same item based on the data profile of the person pushing the cart.

O’Malley first noticed the tags a couple of months ago while buying milk at a Walmart, then spotted them at Carrs and Fred Meyer, the other two dominant chains in the city.

“You can almost not tell the difference, but there is a little button like you can find on the edge,” O’Malley told Alaska Public Media in an interview published November 19. “What that allows them to do is change prices in real time, and we don’t really know how those price changes are happening.”

Data sales now drive a third of net income

The business model behind the tags is laid out in industry publications O’Malley reviewed: consumer data has become a primary revenue stream.

One major grocery company now derives more than 35 percent of its net income from selling that data, though the reporting does not identify which company the figure applies to. When shoppers use loyalty apps or enter phone numbers at checkout for discounts, they are feeding a profile that the retailer can monetize.

“You have become a product that the grocery company is selling, and there aren’t any real guardrails on that.”

Julia O’Malley, columnist, An Alaska Life

Retailers frame dynamic pricing as a way to offer personalized discounts that build loyalty during inflation. But the same systems can raise baseline prices while targeting coupons to specific customers, making it nearly impossible for shoppers to know whether they are paying a fair market rate or a data-adjusted premium.

Geofences and the next layer of tracking

Internal trade publications describe geofencing — virtual perimeters around stores that trigger customized offers when a shopper’s phone crosses the boundary. The discounts appear helpful, but they are powered by location and purchase histories that follow the customer beyond the aisle.

Wisevoter.com, summarizing the same Alaska Public Media interview, notes that shoppers in Anchorage may see prices on the same item change during a single visit, and that offers may depend on the data gathered through those apps.

Seattle banned the practice; Anchorage has no guardrails

O’Malley points out that a similar prohibition in Anchorage, the state’s largest city, would likely force statewide compliance because the chains operate across Alaska. Without regulation, she argues, consumers face a coercive choice: surrender data or pay inflated prices for basics like meatballs.

“It is kind of extortion because, like, we don’t know where that data is going and how else it’s being used to manipulate us to buy stuff.”

Julia O’Malley, columnist, An Alaska Life

What remains unknown

Wisevoter.com emphasizes that it is still unclear whether individual shoppers in Anchorage are actually receiving personalized prices at the shelf, or whether the electronic tags are currently used only for chain-wide price updates. The 35 percent data-revenue figure lacks a named company attached to it.

O’Malley acknowledges the gaps: “I’m not an expert, but that’s the concern, certainly, that the stores can, and they talk a lot about personalized discounts and personalized pricing as ways that stores have been able to weather inflation and other problems for the grocery industry.”

Anchorage, the state’s largest city, holds nearly 40 percent of Alaska’s population — 291,247 residents at the 2020 census — on a peninsula at the head of Cook Inlet. The city began in 1915 as a tent camp for Alaska Railroad construction near Ship Creek and was incorporated in November 1920.

A 1975 merger with the Greater Anchorage Area Borough created the Municipality of Anchorage, which spans 1,961.1 square miles but remains less than 10 percent populated, concentrating most residents in the Anchorage Bowl.

Seattle has banned dynamic pricing, while Anchorage has not introduced comparable legislation.