A family in Catahoula Parish is demanding accountability following the release of body camera footage that captures the final moments of Tyler Nugent’s life.
The footage, obtained by KALB after a nearly two-year investigation, brings new scrutiny to an officer-involved shooting that occurred on January 5, 2025. What began as a response to a domestic violence incident involving the death of Sherry Nugent escalated into a fatal confrontation between the Catahoula Parish Sheriff’s Office (CPSO) Special Response Team (SRT) and her son, Tyler.
For the Nugent family, the video serves as a point of contention against the official narrative provided by law enforcement. Cody Nugent, Tyler’s brother, maintains that the shooting was unjustified, pointing to moments in the footage where he believes his brother was attempting to surrender.
“Let the judge do what needed to be done. Deal justice…Not a police officer taking it into his own hands to be the judge, jury, and Executioner,” Cody Nugent told KALB.
The path to obtaining the records was arduous; it required nearly two years of effort and independent legal representation by KALB to secure footage that the family argues contradicts the accounts provided by the officers involved.
This delay has had material consequences for the family’s pursuit of justice. According to the family, the one-year statute of limitations for filing a wrongful death lawsuit expired while they were still fighting for access to the very evidence needed to build their case.
The incident began when deputies were dispatched to the Nugent household regarding a shooting. Upon discovering Sherry Nugent’s body, the department activated its Special Response Team. Sheriff Toney Edwards later described the deployment as the team’s first legitimate use of its protocols, which are reserved for high-risk scenarios such as barricaded suspects or hostage situations.
After attempts to communicate via megaphone failed, officers approached the home. Detective Dewain Littleton eventually spotted Tyler Nugent, who retreated into a bedroom closet. The team then deployed a chemical agent into the room, though footage shows the officers were not properly equipped for the task, resulting in members choking on the gas.
Discrepancies in the official record further complicate the situation. In his testimony, Lieutenant Ethan House claimed he fired at Tyler because he feared for Detective Littleton’s safety as the detective moved toward the closet. However, KALB’s analysis of the footage suggests Tyler can be heard surrendering before shots were fired, and a firearm appears to be resting on a storage tub nearby rather than in his hands.
Furthermore, the internal documentation of the event was incomplete: the sheriff’s office confirmed that Littleton’s body camera was not operational that night, and the team commander, Gary Vines, admitted he had not been issued a camera at all.
“The moment they took his life, he had no chance at salvation. I’m a Christian… I believe in salvation […] At that moment, they took that from him. Because if they had brought him in the justice system, brought him, apprehended him, took him to jail, [then he would have had] that chance to find Jesus again and ask for his forgiveness.”
The legal process reached a turning point on January 30, 2025, when District Attorney Brad Burget presented the case to a grand jury. After hearing testimony from family members and reviewing the evidence, the grand jury declined to indict Officers House and Littleton.
Sheriff Edwards has publicly stated his support for the officers, emphasizing that the case remains open due to unexplained gunshot wounds found on Tyler’s body that were consistent with a shotgun—a weapon type not used by the SRT.
The sheriff has encouraged anyone with information regarding who might have shot Tyler prior to the deputies’ arrival to contact the Louisiana State Police or the Catahoula Parish Sheriff’s Office.
The family has requested that the District Attorney reintroduce charges against the officers, a move that would require overcoming the hurdle of the prior “no true bill” decision.
Meanwhile, attempts by KALB to verify the training history of the officers involved through the Peace Officer Standards and Training Council were denied, with officials citing an ongoing investigation by the Louisiana Attorney General’s Office. The AG’s office has not provided further comment.
Catahoula Parish, which covers 739 square miles, was founded in 1808 and has undergone more boundary revisions than almost any other in the state. The region was once home to the Troyville Earthworks, which featured a mound reaching 82 feet in height—making it the second-tallest in North America before its destruction for bridge construction.
The area is also known as the origin of the Catahoula Leopard dog, a breed famously associated with historical figures such as Colonel James Bowie and Theodore Roosevelt. Today, the parish remains a largely rural landscape with a population of 8,906 as of the 2020 census.
As the family continues to press for a review of the case, the broader community is left to weigh the conflicting testimonies against the visual evidence provided by the body cameras.
The question of whether the officers acted within the bounds of their training or outside the scope of the law remains the central, unresolved issue. It is unclear whether the state will reopen the investigation based on the newly surfaced footage.