Kalshi Faces Monday Hearing On New York Order That Could Shut Down Exchange Nationwide

Kalshi faces a Monday court hearing that could shutter its entire exchange nationwide, a consequence the company says flows directly from its New York headquarters.

New York Attorney General Letitia James is asking Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Melissa Crane for a temporary restraining order at 11:30 a.m. ET that would bar Kalshi from operating an unlicensed gambling business “within or from New York or to persons in New York.”

Because Kalshi is based in New York, the company argues the phrase “from New York” would effectively impose a nationwide injunction, forcing the liquidation of all open positions and closing the exchange for every customer, everywhere, The Block reported.

The request lands after a chaotic week in federal court. District Judge Lorna Schofield on Friday denied the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s renewed emergency request to block New York’s enforcement case against Kalshi, finding the agency “was unable to show a likelihood of success on the merits that the CEA Commodity Exchange Act preempted state gaming laws,” according to a letter from James’s office cited by The Block.

Hours later, U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick remanded James’s lawsuit back to state court, rejecting Kalshi’s argument that the case belonged in federal jurisdiction.

“If Justice Crane adopts the ‘from New York’ language—effectively imposing a nationwide injunction—the next stop could be the U.S. Supreme Court’s emergency docket”

wrote Daniel Wallach, a sports and gaming attorney, on X Saturday, as reported by The Block.

The preemption fight splits the circuits

The core dispute is whether federal commodities law preempts state gambling statutes. The CFTC has argued in lawsuits across the country that the Commodity Exchange Act gives it exclusive authority over event contracts listed on federally registered exchanges like Kalshi, rendering state sports-betting restrictions inapplicable. Federal appeals courts have split on the question. The Fourth, Sixth, and Ninth Circuits have sided with states; the Third Circuit has sided with Kalshi.

Kalshi Faces Monday Hearing On New York Order That Could Shut Down Exchange Nationwide
Photo: finance.yahoo.com

This week, the Fourth Circuit ruled against Kalshi in its fight with Maryland regulators, though the two judges in the majority disagreed on why. Judge Roger Gregory wrote that federal law does not preempt Maryland’s gambling laws even if Kalshi’s contracts are swaps, while Judge Stephanie Thacker wrote that the contracts are not swaps at all: “What is happening here is sports betting,” according to The Block.

Robinhood watches from the sidelines

The stakes extend beyond Kalshi. Robinhood offers sports contracts through Kalshi’s infrastructure, and the brokerage’s CFO said on October 27 that most flow would move to Rothera—its joint venture exchange with Susquehanna—and to Crypto.com/OG.com “by the end of the year into early next year,” Yahoo Finance reported.

Robinhood shares closed Friday at $62.17, down 9.44% on a day the S&P 500 fell 3.70%, though no source tied the drop directly to the Kalshi news. Event contracts accounted for about 12% of Robinhood’s quarterly revenue in Q2, or $156 million of $1.308 billion total, according to the company’s filings cited by Yahoo Finance.

Robinhood has not disclosed how much of that volume runs through Kalshi specifically.

Competing orders create a legal trap

Kalshi is caught between two contradictory directives. The CFTC issued an emergency order on August 11 directing Kalshi to keep operating. James’s proposed state order would compel it to stop. No court has resolved that conflict.

James’s office pushed back on Kalshi’s characterization of the proposed order, writing to Crane Friday that it “does not seek to ‘shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere,'” and that the order would not stop Kalshi from offering lawful futures or swaps, The Block reported.

The AG’s letter also urged Crane to give the CFTC’s August order no weight, citing a November 10 ruling by U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon that said the order “smacks of a collusive effort between a regulator and regulatee to generate a claim for conflict preemption.”

How the case returned to state court

James filed suit on July 31 under New York Executive Law Section 63(12), alleging Kalshi runs unlicensed sports contracts and allows customers as young as 18 to trade despite a state minimum age of 21.

She seeks damages of three times alleged gains, with one filing putting the minimum at $36 billion, Yahoo Finance reported. Kalshi removed the case to federal court the same day, invoking the federal officer removal statute based on its status as a CFTC-regulated designated contract market.

Broderick found Thursday that the Commodity Exchange Act matters only as Kalshi’s defense, not as a basis for federal jurisdiction. He noted the CFTC had not sought to intervene. Only the Wire Act claim raised a federal issue, he ruled, and that issue was not substantial.

“The scope of laws regulating gambling and lotteries is clearly a matter of predominantly state concern,” Broderick wrote, quoting an earlier decision, according to LocalCryptoNews. He denied James’s request for attorneys’ fees, finding Kalshi had an objectively reasonable basis for removal.

Crane had marked the case disposed on August 3 after Kalshi’s removal, denying James’s injunction motion as moot and saying the state could refile if the case returned. It has now returned.

Kalshi faces New York in state court; 1.2 million users — Agyata Money

Kalshi CEO lobbies attorneys general

While the legal fight escalates, Kalshi attended the Democratic Attorneys General Association meeting in Chicago on Thursday, Politico reported, citing an eyewitness. A Kalshi spokesperson confirmed his attendance but declined to say which attorneys general he met with. It is unclear whether James attended.

Monday’s hearing before Justice Crane will determine whether the exchange goes dark nationwide while the merits play out—a decision that could land on the U.S. Supreme Court’s emergency docket within days.