Kamehameha Schools Asks Judge to Dismiss Third Admissions Lawsuit

The hearing before U.S. District Judge Micah Smith in Honolulu marks the third time the school’s admissions policy has been challenged.

“This lawsuit is trying to siphon off this wealth for the benefit of other people,” John Bash, an attorney for Kamehameha, told the court Tuesday. The school’s estate, derived from the will of Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop, controls land and financial assets valued at well over $15 billion.

Cayetano ruling in 2000.

Kamehameha Schools Asks Judge to Dismiss Third Admissions Lawsuit
Photo: hawaiinewsnow.com

The Standing Fight and the Contract Question

Kamehameha Schools supporters gather as judge hears request to dismiss admissions lawsuit — Hawaii News Now

And if those contracts are race-based, he argued, then the lawsuit should still stand. Cayetano ruling in 2000.

SFFA attorney Cam Norris pushed back. He told the judge that contracts still exist if there is an implicit agreement that students receive a diploma at the end of their schooling. He said the group needs discovery to test Kamehameha’s description of its admissions pipeline, arguing the school’s own declarations cannot be taken at face value without scrutiny.

Congress Affirmed Trust Relationship Repeatedly

He pointed to the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Rice v.

Kamehameha Schools supporters gather as judge hears arguments in admissions lawsuit — Hawaii News Now

Bash disagreed. He argued that Congress has repeatedly affirmed a special political and trust relationship with Native Hawaiians through dozens of federal statutes enacted since the Rice decision, including the Native Hawaiian Health Care Improvement Act and the Native Hawaiian Education Act.

In the end, the judge did not immediately rule on Kamehameha’s motion to dismiss.

A Courtroom Packed With History

The federal courthouse was so full that security opened an overflow room. Kamehameha students filled the gallery in navy blue polos; trustees and lawyers wore green maile lei. Court security took the unusual step of warning the crowd that outbursts could lead to immediate removal.

Mason Fong, a senior at Kamehameha Schools Kapālama, framed the fight in intergenerational terms. “We carry our aloha into that courtroom.”

Kumu Hinaleimoana Wong, a Native Hawaiian leader and Kamehameha graduate, told Hawaii News Now she hopes the case yields not only victory but “more success in garnering kindness and support from non-Hawaiians.”

The admissions policy is one of several landmark Hawaiian programs under legal attack, including the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act — which guarantees homestead leases to those with 50% or more Hawaiian blood — and a Native Hawaiian health scholarship program.