Karl-Anthony Towns Names New Jersey Pizzerias Over New York Pizza

New York Knicks center Karl-Anthony Towns declared New Jersey pizza superior to anything he has eaten in New York, naming two childhood pizzerias as his standard.

“I’ve been to New York many times. And in my times in New York, I still say my childhood pizzeria is still best. Fratelli’s Pizza. Joey D’s as well. They make the best pizza pies I’ve ever had in my life,” Towns said during an appearance on First We Feast’s Hot Ones.

Towns, who grew up in New Jersey, said he has tried pizza in New York on numerous occasions but still prefers the places he visited when he was younger.

The Knicks star specifically singled out Fratelli’s Pizza and Joey D’s, explaining that his experiences eating in New York have not changed his opinion about the best pies. For a Knicks player, that is a bold position to take in a city where pizza is part of the local identity.

Speaking on First We Feast on Hot Ones

His comments fit naturally into the longstanding rivalry between New York and New Jersey over which side produces the better slice. Both have fiercely loyal customers, and arguments about crust, sauce, cheese, and consistency can become surprisingly passionate. New Jersey has even promoted its claim officially.

In February 2020, the state’s government Twitter account declared New Jersey “the pizza capital of the world,” provoking a debate that extended beyond its rivalry with New York. The declaration drew support from residents and food writers, while others rejected the idea that New Jersey should outrank New York or Italy.

Towns’ preference gives that familiar argument another recognizable voice, this time from someone playing for New York’s most prominent basketball franchise. Still, his remarks were more specific than a sweeping dismissal of every New York pizzeria.

He identified two places he loves and said their pizza remains the best he has eaten. That is a personal ranking, shaped by years of familiarity, rather than an objective judgment about every restaurant in either state.

Towns grew up in Piscataway, New Jersey, after being born in nearby Edison, rooting his early food memories in the state’s pizzeria culture. He attended Lake Nelson Seventh-Day Adventist School and Theodore Schor Middle School there, establishing the daily routines that made Fratelli’s Pizza and Joey D’s his benchmarks for a great slice.

Before joining the Knicks ahead of the 2024–25 season, Towns spent nine seasons with the Minnesota Timberwolves after being the first overall pick in the 2015 NBA draft.

That long professional arc only reinforced the loyalty he formed in New Jersey, so when he declared on Hot Ones that his childhood spots still beat anything he has tried in New York, he was drawing on a standard set years before he wore a Knicks jersey.

For the restaurants themselves, an endorsement from a Knicks star is valuable publicity. Naming the businesses gives fans something more concrete than a general declaration that New Jersey makes better pizza. Whether New Yorkers agree is another matter.

Wearing a Knicks jersey does not require Towns to abandon the places he enjoyed before reaching the NBA, and his answer suggests he has no intention of doing so. The basketball allegiance belongs to Madison Square Garden. When the conversation turns to pizza, however, Towns is still backing the New Jersey spots that earned his loyalty long before he became a Knick.