Kentucky Lawmakers Hear County Jail Funding Crisis; Meredith Proposes Reform Bill

Kentucky lawmakers heard Tuesday that county jail funding has hit a crisis point, with local governments transferring nearly $170 million from general funds to keep jails running in fiscal year 2025, a 76 percent jump since 2019.

“We are at a crisis point amongst the county governments related to county jails,” Meredith told the committee. “We are open to listening to any ideas.”

The math that broke the model

The Kentucky Association of Counties laid out the core mismatch: it costs counties about $64 per inmate per day to operate a jail, but the state reimburses only $35.34 for each state inmate housed. That gap, multiplied across thousands of beds, has forced general-fund transfers from $96.5 million in 2019 to $169.7 million last year, Meredith said.

“If they’re housing them in a county jail, that is about half of what it costs on the average to house an inmate, and it’s certainly less than what it costs in our state prison facilities,” Meredith said. “So the state is actually receiving a benefit at the cost of the county in those situations.”

The burden falls hardest on property taxpayers. Grant County Magistrate Jacqalynn Riley said her county’s general fund could no longer subsidize the jail in 2019, prompting a county-wide occupational tax.

Kentucky Lawmakers Hear County Jail Funding Crisis; Meredith Proposes Reform Bill
Photo: floydct.com

“A significant amount of those occupational tax dollars directly goes to running our county jail,” Riley told the committee. “Those funds don’t have the opportunity of upgrading our local roadways, increasing law enforcement or other quality of life initiatives.”

What HB 557 would change

Meredith’s bill attacks the problem on three fronts. First, it would incentivize regional jails — currently only four exist, mostly in Eastern Kentucky — with a $1 million grant for any fiscal court that creates or joins a regional jail authority, plus $500,000 for each existing member county that accepts a new partner.

Second, it would make the state reimburse counties for pretrial felony detainees. Today, a county bears the full cost from arrest through sentencing; if the defendant gets time-served credit, the state never pays for those days.

Third, it would require the Department of Corrections to contract with each fiscal court or regional authority based on actual housing costs, replacing the flat per diem.

Kentucky lawmakers consider rising cost of housing inmates in county jails — WCHS-TV

An emergency regulation that took effect in August — redefining “routine” versus “beyond regular and routine” medical care — is expected to return an estimated $12 million to counties for state inmate healthcare, Meredith noted.

Nemes warns of perverse incentives for county jails

Not everyone is sold. Rep. Jason Nemes, R-Louisville, warned that paying for time-served credit could create a perverse incentive to keep people in county jails longer, especially if home incarceration expands.

“I think that, if we go to the real credit for time served, there will be a significant perverse incentive to keep people in county jails,” Nemes said.

Nemes argued the state should simply take over incarceration entirely rather than layer more Band-Aids on the county model. Meredith said he is still workshopping the bill, including whether opioid settlement funds could cover ankle-monitor costs for indigent defendants on home incarceration — currently $8 to $10 a day versus $63.44 to house them.

Rep. Savannah Maddox, R-Dry Ridge, said she has heard the pitch three times and believes fixing the system is the General Assembly’s responsibility. “I think we can clearly see that this is a problem that doesn’t just affect a few of us, it affects all of us,” she said.

Meredith will refine the proposal before the 2027 session

The legislature cannot act until the 2027 regular session convenes Jan. 5. Until then, Meredith said he will keep refining the proposal with colleagues and stakeholders.