Lansing City Council is trying a new legal lever to force the removal of 26 automated license plate readers from city streets after the mayor and police chief ignored a 7-1 vote to cancel the contracts.
The draft ordinance, introduced at the council’s Nov. 16 session, would prohibit stationary ALPR cameras from being placed or affixed in the city’s public rights-of-way, The Lansing State Journal reported. Council President Peter Spadafore cast the lone dissenting vote in August when the body first demanded the cameras come down; Mayor Andy Schor and Lansing Police Department leaders subsequently disregarded that resolution.
“That was a pretty clear vote, so I was surprised that they didn’t want to move to take these down,” said Ward 1 Councilmember Ryan Kost, who asked city attorneys to draft the ban legislation alongside Councilmember Adam Hussain. Kost believes the city currently operates 26 cameras at seven locations.

The rights-of-way workaround
City Attorney Gregory Venker gave the council a narrow green light in an Oct. 24 opinion. He wrote that while the council cannot pass an ordinance dictating how the police department uses ALPR cameras or the evidence they generate, it does hold primary regulatory authority over rights-of-way and may restrict their occupation for certain purposes — including the placement of technology by the police department.
The mayor’s office agrees with that reading. “He read the City Attorney’s opinion and agrees with it,” city spokesman Scott Bean said in an email to the State Journal. “As the legislative body, Council has the power to craft ordinances. He will follow the Council proceedings and discussion closely. As Mayor, he is tasked with executing ordinances passed by City Council.”
“Council may not pass an ordinance detailing how ALPR cameras or the evidence they generate may (or may not) be used by the Lansing Police Department. However, City Council has the primary regulatory authority over rights-of-way in the City of Lansing and may restrict its occupation for certain purposes by certain entities, including the placement of technology by the Police Department.”
— Gregory Venker, City Attorney
The proposed ordinance now sits with the Committee on City Operations, whose members are Ward 1 representative Ryan Kost, at-large councilmembers Trini Pehlivanoglu and Clara Martinez. They are scheduled to meet at 4 p.m. Dec. 10 in the new City Hall at 425 S. Grand Ave., according to the State Journal.
Lansing's City Council making new effort to shutter Flock cameras https://t.co/QxjENchXrG
Police and business push back
Lansing Police Chief Rob Backus provided the 26-camera count to Kost in April. In a Nov. 11 statement, the department argued the cameras are valued for finding leads, identifying vehicles connected to crimes and solving cases that may otherwise go unsolved.
“Losing access to this technology would leave our officers without an important investigative tool and make it more difficult to bring answers and justice to victims and their families,” the statement said. The department added it remains open to conversations about safeguards and responsible use.
The Lansing Regional Chamber of Commerce has also weighed in, urging the council to oppose a ban and instead set rules for how the cameras are used. Chamber CEO Tim Daman told WILX that public safety is a top concern for downtown employers. “We hear a lot about the panhandling and employees that are being harassed on their way from parking lots and into their place of employment,” Daman said.
“The technology aspect is not going to be removed from law enforcement and public safety; we should be leaning into this and supporting our first responders, police and firefighters in their daily role.” The chamber acknowledged privacy worries and wants the city to be transparent about data storage and management, The Mitten Daily reported.
Privacy advocates say data is ‘up for grabs’
Opponents argue the cameras capture far more than license plates — photographing entire vehicles, bicyclists, and pedestrians — and feed data into a searchable nationwide network. More than 50 people spoke against the cameras at the council’s Aug. 24 session, and opposition has continued at subsequent meetings, the State Journal noted.
Lia Lilley, an advocate with the group DeFlock Lansing, told WILX the core concern is what happens to the information once collected. “We are giving all of this information to public corporations that can fold at any moment,” Lilley said. “That data that involves all of us is essentially up for grabs and can be sold and resold to the heart’s content of the companies in question.”
A Flock camera outside the Red Roof Inn in Lansing was photographed on Nov. 19. Resident Balthazar Ferguson, who submitted the photo, wrote that no warrant is required to search the footage and that data can potentially be accessed by Flock employees, other municipalities, or federal agencies with credentials.
Regional context and what comes next
The Clinton County Sheriff’s Office paused use of its sole camera in October after county commissioners raised concerns, WLNS TV-6 reported. Deflock’s interactive map logged nearly three dozen cameras in the city of Lansing and approximately 116 across Ingham and Eaton counties as of August, though some are privately owned.
Mayor Andy Schor, born in 1975 on Long Island, moved to Michigan to attend the University of Michigan and later worked as a paid staffer on the Clinton-Gore campaign. He served a decade on the Ingham County Board of Commissioners, where he helped create the Ingham County Land Bank in 2005, before winning three terms in the Michigan House representing the 68th district.
Schor regards the 2013 passage of the Healthy Michigan Medicaid expansion, which enrolled more than 600,000 residents, as the most important vote of his legislative career. He became the first Jewish mayor of Lansing in 2018.
The Lansing City Council is not scheduled to meet again until Dec. 7, and that agenda has not been released, The Mitten Daily reported. The Committee on City Operations meets Dec. 10.