Madison police solved fewer than half of all property crimes over the last decade even as homicide clearance rates hovered above 80 percent, The Cap Times reported.
The gap between what the department solves and what it doesn’t defines the daily reality for victims of theft and burglary in Wisconsin’s capital. Most crimes reported to the Madison Police Department are property offenses.
Fewer than one in five cases is typically solved, the FBI’s clearance metric requires. Homicides are far rarer — 67 reported from 2015 to 2025 — but the department cleared 67 of them, an 82 percent rate under federal counting rules.
Having headed the Madison Police Department for under two years despite nearly three decades with the agency, Patterson acknowledged the disparity in an interview. “I think we’re exceptional not just because of the work that we’re producing and the service we’re delivering, but it’s because we recognize we can always do better and (are) constantly trying to improve,” he said.
Specialized teams replace geographic beats
One year ago the department finished a shift to crime-specific investigative units. Detectives once worked cases by police district; now they specialize in homicide, burglary, sexual assault, or crimes against children. The burglary unit offers the clearest early signal: clearance rates that languished below 10 percent until 2022, then began to increase, jumping to 24 percent last year.
“I think it’s allowed us to get a better understanding of what’s happening in the city, how to address it, and maybe come up with some different ways of going about dealing with them,”
said Detective Lt. Glenn Davis, who oversees 12 detectives and two sergeants.
Sexual-assault clearances have also risen sharply. The rate was 28 percent in 2014; it reached 63 percent at one point a decade later and remained at nearly 40 percent last year. Patterson attributes the increase partially to cultural changes. Victims feel more at ease going to law enforcement, and the department collaborates with support groups such as the RCC Sexual Violence Resource Center, he said.
Staffing ceiling limits gains
The department fields about 600 people on a $103 million annual budget — the city’s largest — but 67 are detectives. Each detective typically investigates 45 to 50 cases a year, according to Assistant Chief Angie Kamoske. The property-crime unit had nearly 400 burglaries to investigate last year.
“Sometimes it’s a significant hurdle to follow every case as far as possible when you have 400 of them that require your attention,” Patterson said. He cited a September north-side homicide where investigators worked around the clock before a person of interest was arrested in Los Angeles weeks later. “They ran into a burnout moment… capacity is often limited by the number of people you have.”
Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway asked city agencies this year to identify about 2% in cuts for next year — about $2 million for police. “Our top three departments by people are Police, Fire and Metro (Transit), and it’s true for all of them that we have not been able to meaningfully add that many positions,” Rhodes-Conway said.
The mayor’s executive budget kept staffing mostly level, adding two positions to support the rollout of body-worn cameras. The City Council unanimously approved the budget Nov. 10. Wisconsin law enforcement agencies are largely shielded from deep budget reductions because municipalities like Madison risk losing state aid if they cut police staffing or funding.
Trust fracture after Corey Ruiz shooting
“Without our community trust, I mean our public safety crumbles, frankly,”
Patterson said.
About 300 officers serve in patrol while 67 — roughly one-sixth of sworn personnel — are detectives, Patterson said. The majority of Madison officers work in patrol and traffic enforcement units, which answer emergency calls and watch the roadways, instead of concentrating on crime investigations.
The specialized-team model is still too new to judge across every crime category. But the numbers that exist suggest focus helps where caseloads allow it. Whether the city can sustain that focus without more detectives — or deeper community cooperation — remains the open question.